To maintain the 'modern bhangra' atmosphere, headlining this event will be the symbol of fusing Bhangra with western music himself, Manak - E. Other headliners tba.
Judging will be that of a modern competition, there will be no extra points awarded for traditional aspects of bhangra (live singing, etc.).
However, this is STILL a bhangra competition. Points will be awarded for synchronization, formations, execution, stunts, and degree of difficulty as with all competitions.
Some may say this will bias local teams compared to long distance teams, but in actuality it will benefit the team who puts on the most entertaining show.
Quote from: FTW Entertainment on December 08, 2009, 11:32:39 PMJudging will be that of a modern competition, there will be no extra points awarded for traditional aspects of bhangra (live singing, etc.). Fail.Quote from: FTW Entertainment on December 08, 2009, 11:32:39 PMHowever, this is STILL a bhangra competition. Points will be awarded for synchronization, formations, execution, stunts, and degree of difficulty as with all competitions.No, this is the definition of any dance competition. What differentiates this as a Bhangra competition? Quote from: FTW Entertainment on December 08, 2009, 11:32:39 PMSome may say this will bias local teams compared to long distance teams, but in actuality it will benefit the team who puts on the most entertaining show.Based on what reasoning? The more fans- the more lively a crowd, no? Quote from: FTW Entertainment on December 08, 2009, 11:32:39 PMTo maintain the 'modern bhangra' atmosphere, headlining this event will be the symbol of fusing Bhangra with western music himself, Manak - E. Other headliners tba. Please review Pioneer Bhangra 2009 opinions regarding this decision. Best of luck.
Come why would u pay so much for a sing that forgets his on lyrics when he tries to lip sing or even PA get someone legit like Malwa, cheema, geeta zailder, any of the mann's and if u really want to get someone from UK get JK.So there is going to be 2 comps in Modesto one in feb n one in April dammm but the idea of all modern comp is wack because first of all norcal is like heaven for traditional bhangra with teams like heeray babc GS 3d capital. And with semi trad. Teams like BK virse deh waris n lbc why would u want to have a modern comp.
In order to do so we need to put on a lively, energetic, fun show that caters to the general population. Traditional teams are fantastic and put in countless amounts of effort into their routines, but too many times the audience is 'bored' with their performance.
Funny how people say that a competition is shady/wack/whatever because its supposed to be a traditional comp but modern teams place, yet Norcal Bhangra is coming out and saying exactly what they're looking for and people are still finding a reason to cry about it. Any traditional team that comes to this comp will know that that they cant rely on just being traditional, they have to be high energy and entertaining.
Quote from: [Sher] Imran on December 10, 2009, 02:32:11 PMFunny how people say that a competition is shady/wack/whatever because its supposed to be a traditional comp but modern teams place, yet Norcal Bhangra is coming out and saying exactly what they're looking for and people are still finding a reason to cry about it. Any traditional team that comes to this comp will know that that they cant rely on just being traditional, they have to be high energy and entertaining. Imran, you are a wise man....somehow people will figure out a way to bitch...To the organizers of Norcal, way to come right out and say exactly what you are looking for, although I think you may have explained yourself a bit way too much...a simple...brief sentence or two explaining that you will not be awarding extra points for having a singer, band, etc..would have sufficed. As far as Manak-E..I have never heard of an organizer being so straight forward...hahah...it is the only person they could book...so..at least they are telling you what happened? Kudos to you FTW in your candidness, but perhaps you don't need to disclose everything...as Swi said, your reasons are your reasons..you don't need to explain to us every aspect of the competition..I suggest all modern teams and traditional apply to this competition as it seems to be creating quite a level playing field in that regard...I would be surprised if the line up didn't come out stellar...given all the teams in the area that would be interested. It seems competition organizers can never win...you can have hours and hours of bitching about how the organizers aren't saying enough, yet at the same time...here we have a case where the competition has disclosed everything to the community, and there is a problem with it. They are throwing the competition, they can decide to have the rubric geared to whatever they choose..if you don't like it, don't apply...it is a 100 times better than a comp being vague about what they are looking for, which is generally the case...and fuels half the fires that we have over judging.
I think the word "traditional" should be clarified since it has such an ambiguous definition. For me, traditional means: a team who executes with grace and folk (nakhra, joshe, lachak) understands the importance of the way vardiyaan should be worn, and distinguishes their routine with respect to different segments (Khunda segment, saap segment, jhummar, dhamaal, phumaniyaan, mirza, jodiyaan, etc.) and appropriate music (live or recorded) selection. To me it does not matter if a "traditional" team dances live or on music as long the entire set follows certain elements. Now, the flaw in FTW's description is that they are labeling a traditional team as being "all live". That is a vague definition. According to your description, you are only going to have empire-esque teams (what I call "modern" teams) applying who do not base their choreo/music on a certain folk/bhangra elements. Also, can you explain your statement, "Points will be awarded for synchronization, formations, execution, stunts, and degree of difficulty as with all competitions." What kind of execution are you talking about? This could mean ANYTHING. Hip hop execution? "Bangra" execution? "Modern execution" (creating your own moves? doing jugni to a jhummar song)? And can you explain degree of difficulty? Are you referring to difficulty in choreo? Does a team have to have at least 16 count moves like they did 5 years ago or else the action isnt considered difficult? This has nothing to do with "bitching". This has everything to do with you trying to be innovative and being the FIRST competition that requires music with hip hop and "chart topping" hits. You have to elaborate. Teams already incorporate hip hop beats and bass in their mixes. What makes this competition "the first" of its kind? You wrote "There is a heavy emphasis on the quality, energy, and fluidity of the music and how well the routine fits the music." Isnt this what teams have been doing already? Isnt this why in the "team mixes" section of btf you have teams posting their mixes and ppl say WOW THAT WAS A SICK MIX!!!! What sets your competition apart from others? As of right now there is nothing. Your descriptions have bean vague and do not offer anything "new" to the circuit. P.S. I know some of you are gonna jump on my sack and say "but bhangra is evolving BLAH BLAH BLAH". This is true, but there are aspects that will not change.