Thanks Manjot, I found it.
Saleem, I switched off of Blue Vista back to the default. It's nice to have different options, but maybe it's better to just have one standard theme for everyone? It seems like it puts a lot of burden on you to tweak each theme to implement new features, and in the end it's probably not worth the effort.
One thing I will say I like better about Blue Vista, besides the color scheme, is that it seems to be fixed width, and the default theme is not. It just feels like it places more strain on my eyes to read things that a r e s o w i d e in the default theme, but fixed width has its problems, too, on larger screens.