• Bhangra discussion is still going strong. Join us in our Facebook group!

    New user registration has been closed (as it was entirely spam). We encourage you to post in our Facebook group, even if it's a followup to an existing thread. BTF will continue to be archived and hosted here - Saleem

Buckeye Mela 7 - Feedback, Concerns, Suggestions!

BuckeyeMela

New Member
Messages
11
[SIZE=medium]Dear BTF,[/SIZE]

[SIZE=medium]We would like to reach out to everyone in light of our up-and-coming competition, and received any and all feedback, concerns, suggestions, and questions anyone may have regarding our competition. All opinions and comments are most welcome! Our goal is to strive to become one of the best competitions out there. Instead of waiting until after our competition this year to receive feedback, which usually doesn't get implemented very well because of changes in leadership that occur from year-to-year, we would like to ask everyone before our competition happens about suggestions you all may have and what you would like to see from Buckeye Mela this year. Going into our 7th year we would like to be able to take Mela to the next level, and all your opinions matter and will truly be taken to heart![/SIZE]

[SIZE=medium]Thanks in advance for your time,[/SIZE]
[SIZE=medium]The Buckeye Mela Team[/SIZE]

[SIZE=medium]Buckeye Mela 7 - Srujan 2014 will be taking place February 14-15, 2014 in Columbus, OH.[/SIZE]
[SIZE=medium]www.buckeyemela.com[/SIZE]
 

nmistry2

New Member
Messages
84
Hey


I went last year and had a lot of fun at this competition. I was brand new to the circuit last year and didn't know what to expect but I definitely had a good time. I can definitely give my input to make it better.


1) For the mixer, make it so the lineup is chosen at random. Make it so we play games to choose the order out of a hat or something rather then picking our exact position in the line up. It becomes unfair and the mixer becomes over competitive and aggressive for no reason. Plus you don't want tire and stress teams out before they go on stage.


2) Tech time was great we got a lot of time and it went effectively the only thing was maybe some security or something, we didn't appreciate how a lot of times were watching our tech rehearsal from the side, whether it was your control or not it could have been.


3) Push the liaisons to be there. Although our liaisons did help us out we still had to search for own food and convenience stores, we could have used a little more help. Plus one of our liaisons wasn't there ever, we saw them once at the beginning and thats it


4) You should consider having some method of storage for each team or having more space backstage, we ended up losing half our props which are not cheap and because there were so many people scattered in a small place it felt really cramped. Some teams got more space then others which was kind of unfair i know space is limited but it could be organized better.


other then that, stage time, judge meetings, the actual competition, the after party, the stage, the crew, I definitely had a really fun time and think you guys are doing a really good job with the competition
 

ashvin.kapur

Member
Messages
34
I'm not too sure about the last comment made about mixer. I tend to hate it when competition organizers make a big deal about doing well at the mixer games and then show order turns out to be double blind. If that's going to be the case, then tell everyone the mixer games make no difference, and then split teams up so that people actually mingle. I don't have a problem with having the mixer games determine lineup because I look at it like this: Coming into the competition, no team has any distinct advantage at mixer games (no school is inherently better at dumb social activities). So really, it is a random way of choosing lineup, but it's fun and competitive. I love competition and think it's a great way to bond with your team and others, so I liked the way Srujan did it when we were there. I thought it was the best mixer I had been to in terms of structure.
 

nmistry2

New Member
Messages
84
ashvin.kapur said:
I'm not too sure about the last comment made about mixer. I tend to hate it when competition organizers make a big deal about doing well at the mixer games and then show order turns out to be double blind. If that's going to be the case, then tell everyone the mixer games make no difference, and then split teams up so that people actually mingle. I don't have a problem with having the mixer games determine lineup because I look at it like this: Coming into the competition, no team has any distinct advantage at mixer games (no school is inherently better at dumb social activities). So really, it is a random way of choosing lineup, but it's fun and competitive. I love competition and think it's a great way to bond with your team and others, so I liked the way Srujan did it when we were there. I thought it was the best mixer I had been to in terms of structure.

Competitive nature is fun and great but then when people start to cheat and get overly competitive at the mixer it loses the essence of the mixer. The mixer is more so about meeting other teams more so then show order.
 

ashvin.kapur

Member
Messages
34
Agreed on the point of the mixer. I just think I've mixed better and met more people with the competitive aspect alive. But I see where you're coming from. Probably just a personal preference
 

yraparla

SwizzeeMusic.com
Messages
2,072
nmistry2 said:
Competitive nature is fun and great but then when people start to cheat and get overly competitive at the mixer it loses the essence of the mixer. The mixer is more so about meeting other teams more so then show order.
ashvin.kapur said:
Agreed on the point of the mixer. I just think I've mixed better and met more people with the competitive aspect alive. But I see where you're coming from. Probably just a personal preference
I'd argue that choice of game is very important here. I like the random 'dance around an awkward committee member in a chair' games if it's not competitive. If that's deciding the order it's a giant clusterfuck. Boston/South Asian Showdown had the best games, if you decide to go for games=show order I would look to see how they did it. We had fun, mingled, and were competitive. It's shitty games or drawn out games that make the experience poor.
 

faizan

Just shut up and dance
Messages
1,736
mixer should be light and relaxed. teams should be afforded the right to enjoy themselves and network. By pitting teams against each other you gain nothing. You just have bitter teams who couldn't run fast enough in a game of duck duck goose.


You don't ask teams in major sports like basketball, boxing, soccer or football to hang out the night before a major game.


Show order should be decided randomly. What number you get is strictly luck. And besides, other than number 1 in the show, you still have a decent chance of placing. And if you get 1, well then god bless ya.
 

ashvin.kapur

Member
Messages
34
+1 to game choice being paramount. But from my experience at Srujan2012, they did something similar to "minute to win it" and it was really well done, competitive, and still a ton of fun
 

Shahrukh

Active Member
Messages
505
faizan said:
mixer should be light and relaxed. teams should be afforded the right to enjoy themselves and network. By pitting teams against each other you gain nothing. You just have bitter teams who couldn't run fast enough in a game of duck duck goose.


You don't ask teams in major sports like basketball, boxing, soccer or football to hang out the night before a major game.


Show order should be decided randomly. What number you get is strictly luck. And besides, other than number 1 in the show, you still have a decent chance of placing. And if you get 1, well then god bless ya.
should always be decided randomly.

Show order shouldnt matter, IF you have proper judges who have a lot of experience dancing in the circuit and can remember what the first team did while watching the 10th team in the lineup, and give specific examples to each team with relevant feedback. Judge upgrade time.
 

nmistry2

New Member
Messages
84
Shahrukh said:
faizan said:
mixer should be light and relaxed. teams should be afforded the right to enjoy themselves and network. By pitting teams against each other you gain nothing. You just have bitter teams who couldn't run fast enough in a game of duck duck goose.


You don't ask teams in major sports like basketball, boxing, soccer or football to hang out the night before a major game.


Show order should be decided randomly. What number you get is strictly luck. And besides, other than number 1 in the show, you still have a decent chance of placing. And if you get 1, well then god bless ya.
should always be decided randomly.

Show order shouldnt matter, IF you have proper judges who have a lot of experience dancing in the circuit and can remember what the first team did while watching the 10th team in the lineup, and give specific examples to each team with relevant feedback. Judge upgrade time.

Perfectly said man I agree completely. In an ideal world the show order shouldn't matter at all especially cause they have a rubric that decides the winners based off of each individual dance but because that isn't happening i think a random order should be decided because realistically no one should complain that we lost cause of show order if its random.
 

sganesha

New Member
Messages
17
I personally like it when comps do a random show order or one based off of when they hand in things and use the mixer for something like extra tech time ( which is always nice). Lightens up the mood during mixers but keeps people still involved.
 

pavbhaji91

Member
Messages
149
Haha I remember when Burgh did this thing where the order in picking a number out of a hat for show order was based on who handed in registration materials the quickest. Though the probability of each team choosing a certain spot in the lineup remains the same and equal, I thought it was funny that they did that.
 

nmistry2

New Member
Messages
84
sganesha said:
I personally like it when comps do a random show order or one based off of when they hand in things and use the mixer for something like extra tech time ( which is always nice). Lightens up the mood during mixers but keeps people still involved.

This is very true, thats definitely a fair perk that will get people involved but not overly competitive
 

smehta313

Active Member
Messages
382
I wasn't there last year, but I was there 2 years ago when RU Bhangra placed 2nd.
I'm sure most teams won't argue with this either, but when we placed in 2012 Second Place had no monetary compensation.

Now, I love trophies as much as the next guy, but when teams work as hard as they do I don't think offering a cash prize for second place in both the fusion and bhangra category would be too much of a hit.


Not sure if this was done last year, but just one suggestion from my perspective. Good luck with the competition this year.
 

RsKderpu

Member
Messages
264
In my opinion, the best ways to decide the order of a competition are:


1- Have the head of the committee or a judge randomly pull a paper from a box/hat/etc which have team names on them.


2- Come up with interesting games that have nothing to do with bhangra. Something "outside the box" to keep things interesting/fair
 

Shyam

New Member
Messages
14
smehta313 said:
I wasn't there last year, but I was there 2 years ago when RU Bhangra placed 2nd.
I'm sure most teams won't argue with this either, but when we placed in 2012 Second Place had no monetary compensation.

Now, I love trophies as much as the next guy, but when teams work as hard as they do I don't think offering a cash prize for second place in both the fusion and bhangra category would be too much of a hit.


Not sure if this was done last year, but just one suggestion from my perspective. Good luck with the competition this year.

This is very true. Last year TerraPind won 2nd and we had no monetary compensation as well. Maybe there can be a cut in the amount the 1st team wins which can be given as a cash prize to the 2nd place time. Just a suggestion! Can't wait to come compete again this year!
 
Top