• Bhangra discussion is still going strong. Join us in our Facebook group!

    New user registration has been closed (as it was entirely spam). We encourage you to post in our Facebook group, even if it's a followup to an existing thread. BTF will continue to be archived and hosted here - Saleem

Actual question about judging competitions

siddyp

Tough times never last, but tough people do.
Messages
1,270
After reading through some of the previous threads, I'm kinda confused.

In a couple threads I read that a judge compares each team and rates them 1 - x number of teams at the competition. After reading judging rubrics, i thought a judge was supposed to fill out a rubric and add up the points. (10 for execution, 8 for traditionalism, etc. = 90) These points would be distributed according to the judges opinion on the set. Then you add up points between all judges, drop low and high etc etc depending on competition rules. Then you rank the teams according to highest points.

Where did this watch, compare, and rank business come from? Or did I miss something.

Clarification please.
 

Kaur

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,294
Honestly what happens at the juding table, even more then that what happens when judges are discussing scores behinh closed doors no one knows.
When I first came into bhangra I always though that the judges mark according to the ruberic, add up all the scores and the team with the highest score wins.

But then I realized that other factors matter, sometimes if you go first the judges will go back and re-evaluate the performance, or if you go right after intermission and the seats arent full.

Now when it comes to a personal bias that cannot be controlled. Im sure that before a judge even sees a teams performacne they already know who's bhangra they are a fan of and whos they arent.
 

campy614

New Member
Messages
666
I mean, it depends on the judge. Ultimately they're comparing and ranking teams-however they choose to do so is on them. There are plenty of other factors-that's life.
 

MPElive

Ehhh Folllkkkkkk Ahhh !!
Messages
323
From my judging experience, I have always followed the judging criteria that was provided by the committee. They actually vary from competition to competition and usually all the judges I have worked with are on the same page when it comes to the placing. If we are ever unsure, we basically go back to the scoresheets and look at the comments made while watching the performance. At the end, the points are tallied and given to the committee.
 

Saleem

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
1,928
MPElive said:
From my judging experience, I have always followed the judging criteria that was provided by the committee. They actually vary from competition to competition and usually all the judges I have worked with are on the same page when it comes to the placing. If we are ever unsure, we basically go back to the scoresheets and look at the comments made while watching the performance. At the end, the points are tallied and given to the committee.
+1 to what Atinder said. You follow the rubric, assign points for traditionality, creativity, execution, etc as determined by the rubric. The rubric is the law of the land for the competition, whether it decides to award 15% or 50% traditionality, you judge based on that.

I think when someone says "judged against the others at the competition" it could mean 1 of two things
1. i will make sure my scores are consistent. that is, if I gave one team a 21/25 on creativity, and later i judge another team and give them 21/25, that those 2 dances were analogous in their levels of creativity. this is called consistency, and there's nothing wrong with it. This helps prevent biases to teams who go early or immediately after intermission.

2. judges' feedback may sound comparitive but I don’t think anyone says “their saap work is 9/10 vs yours which was 6/10”, because thats not what the rubric looks like. What you may find during the feedback session, for example, is “your jhummar was a bit stiff and choreo repetitive. You should vary the music a bit with some slower and some faster, and vary the jhummar choreography. I would consider taking advantage of the co-ed nature of your team and increase interaction between the guy and girl in the jodi”. The comparison may come if you continue to say “team XYZ excelled in this aspect—check out their jhummar section and see if it illustrates this point”.
 
Top