• Bhangra discussion is still going strong. Join us in our Facebook group!

    New user registration has been closed (as it was entirely spam). We encourage you to post in our Facebook group, even if it's a followup to an existing thread. BTF will continue to be archived and hosted here - Saleem

All Competition Organizers - PLEASE READ!

dheerja

Member
Messages
607
Hi all,


Since my initial post on competition behavior (see here http://bhangrateamsforum.com/discuss/main-bhangra-discussion/behavior-at-competitions/) there's been a tremendous response from the bhangra community.


I'm actively working on a few initiatives to get this rolling, and competition organizers I need your help!!


I'm currently drafting a document that will detail a set of behavioral and safety standards so competitions can provide a united front against inappropriate behavior, and also provide a safe place for teams. Following this will be a pledge for organizers AND teams to sign so we can all commit to adhering to these standards, and hold anyone who violates these accountable.


In order to make an impact, I want to present a series of statistics on monetary damage, legal repercussions, # of violent incidents, etc. that have occurred at competitions.


Competition Organizers - please post your contact info here or email me at dheerja.kaur@gmail.com so I can ask you a set of questions and group these statistics. All data will be presented anonymously unless I ask you otherwise.
 

Aneeta

New Member
Messages
92
I read through some of that thread (it was so lengthy). Most of it seems like a good idea. Certain points I did not agree with. But email me! I am PMing you. =)

Great initiative Dheerja!
 

singhk1

New Member
Messages
416
I think your blowing this out of proportion, what competitions needs safety regulation
 

mafzal

Judge / Dancer
Messages
2,098
Pankaja said:
I actually just posted about this in the Fever thread, but Fever committee hired bouncers to be in the hotel after the Afterparty let out. HUGE plus that all comps should def do. I don't remember hearing about or seeing any major issues or big problems with fights and breaking stuff at the hotel, and I feel like the bouncers played a key role in that
NICE
 

aneeshsahni

New Member
Messages
60
Mariam said:
Pankaja said:
I actually just posted about this in the Fever thread, but Fever committee hired bouncers to be in the hotel after the Afterparty let out. HUGE plus that all comps should def do. I don't remember hearing about or seeing any major issues or big problems with fights and breaking stuff at the hotel, and I feel like the bouncers played a key role in that
NICE

I think it'd be better to resolve these issues without bouncers. It's costly to have bouncers there all the time and, as shown in the fever thread, when the bouncers weren't around there were still issues. Maybe you can have teams make a large deposit and they'd get it back after the competition if they don't fuck stuff up. That way the committee's money can go toward improving the competition itself.
 

yraparla

SwizzeeMusic.com
Messages
2,072
aneeshsahni said:
Mariam said:
Pankaja said:
I actually just posted about this in the Fever thread, but Fever committee hired bouncers to be in the hotel after the Afterparty let out. HUGE plus that all comps should def do. I don't remember hearing about or seeing any major issues or big problems with fights and breaking stuff at the hotel, and I feel like the bouncers played a key role in that
NICE

I think it'd be better to resolve these issues without bouncers. It's costly to have bouncers there all the time and, as shown in the fever thread, when the bouncers weren't around there were still issues. Maybe you can have teams make a large deposit and they'd get it back after the competition if they don't fuck stuff up. That way the committee's money can go toward improving the competition itself.
Doesn't solve the issue of groupies/complete randos running around being idiots. Teams cannot be responsible for every person who claims affiliation. A deposit only work so far to that end, but bouncers resolve immediate and physical issues and, while costly, give better liability for the competition. It's an unfortunate cost, but perhaps one that is simply necessary given the state of affairs now.
 

DamanSingh

Member
Messages
849
aneeshsahni said:
I think it'd be better to resolve these issues without bouncers. It's costly to have bouners there all the time and, as shown in the fever thread, when the bouncers weren't around there were still issues. Maybe you can have teams make a large deposit and they'd get it back after the competition if they don't fuck stuff up. That way the committee's money can go toward improving the competition itself.
I feel like a security deposit might deter teams from applying. I think the most effective solution would involve not permitting disruptive teams to return.


The bouncers were included in our contract with the hotel; they came at no additional cost. Definitely something competitions may want to look into.
 

aneeshsahni

New Member
Messages
60
Fair point about the randos.


Not permitting disruptive teams to return is definitely part of the solution. Comp organizers have seemed hesitant about officially calling out teams, which is important. Maybe Fever can set an example--as per your post in behavior at comps (the superlong thread), seems like there were still issues at the hotel.
 

RsKderpu

Member
Messages
264
singhk1 said:
I think your blowing this out of proportion, what competitions needs safety regulation

Almost every competition but more specifically, Motor City Bhangra. A bhangra competition is an event for EVERYONE to enjoy and have fun (regardless of whether a team places or not). There is always that one person or group of persons' that take things too far just because they didn't place or win 1st place. That's why action is being taken in order to provide safety for those who want to enjoy dancing and watching dancers, instead of having a constant fear of something going wrong.
 

itsG

New Member
Messages
309
RsKderpu said:
singhk1 said:
I think your blowing this out of proportion, what competitions needs safety regulation

Almost every competition but more specifically, Motor City Bhangra. A bhangra competition is an event for EVERYONE to enjoy and have fun (regardless of whether a team places or not). There is always that one person or group of persons' that take things too far just because they didn't place or win 1st place. That's why action is being taken in order to provide safety for those who want to enjoy dancing and watching dancers, instead of having a constant fear of something going wrong.
the person or group of persons' that take things too far because they didn't win first are more than likely directly the team which can be avoided by preventing the team to return. but it wouldnt prevent the random people which I feel ended up being more of a problem at Motor City
 

xlnc

Member
Messages
53
I have been following this topic very closely ever since it was brought up couple months ago, however I felt since I was not a competition participant on regular basis, my advice would be irrelevant, but after following the discussion I would like to make a few points.


We can make all the reports all the affirmed rule changes, however if we cannot force a penalty on a team we cannot make them behave better. Think about it hockey or like football, the NHL takes care when a player shows disorderly conduct.


What I propose for the Bhangra Circuit is a self-governing oversite effort. Bhangra Team Forums serves as the best place to do it and I am more than willing to dedicate my time to help develop this (moderators can contact me on that). I have done logistics for something like this locally for the Ultimate Frisbee League which oversights over 400 players.


Essentially the following procedure could be set up on BTF.


  • BTF makes a competitions repository where each competition is listed. Once the line up for a competition is made public the organizers add teams to the competition for the entire community to see
  • This repository also has all the teams listed on it, and each dancer for each team will have to be registered in this repository to dance on stage. Basically they have a ID, attached to them on BTF (separate from there forum account)
  • After each competition the organizers rate each team and its dancers for various fields, such as hotel room state after leaving , rowdy behavior etc. by giving them a rating out of 5 stars, Organizers can attach pics etc other accounts to support the rating they gave.
  • This rating is visible to the whole community to see
  • The rating is calculated on the basis of individual dancer's score, so if a dancer hops teams, his or her rating will now effect the overall rating of there new team. Similary once a team removes a player from active roster, there individual score will not effect the team
  • We can also have a decay effect on current rating, that over a period of lets say 24 months if no negative feedback comes for a dancer, their negative rating from the past is weighted less heavily than new ones
  • Finally, people will say that its usually not the dancers, its the people accompanying them that cause all the ruckus. Usually speaking - from my personal perspective events offer 1+1 VIP passes, that is 1 for the dancer and 1 for the entourage. So a team of 15 can bring upto 15 as an entourage. We can just rate the entourage separately and relatively have the rating effect the final team rating
Basically what this does is that it adds an incentive for teams to be on a good behavior and has a backlash effect if they show poor manners.


The whole point behind this system is that organizers can use it as a tool to choose which team they want to invite, as organizers usually change from one year to another but now they have this whole history they can look at and see what to expect from a team. Finally it also serves as a self regulatory forum, where teams know that if they mess up the hotel, have a fight, there will be a real repercussion to the name of their team.


These are just my thoughts about what can be done. Certainly there can be other ideas which solve the same problem in a better and effective manner.
 
Top