• Bhangra discussion is still going strong. Join us in our Facebook group!

    New user registration has been closed (as it was entirely spam). We encourage you to post in our Facebook group, even if it's a followup to an existing thread. BTF will continue to be archived and hosted here - Saleem

Bhangra set labeled as "too folk"????

Status
Not open for further replies.

Kartik

Member
Messages
319
voxanimus said:
Kartik said:
desi99 said:
"too folk" also means "too clean"


good stuff virsa
Not at all; Empire's considered one of the cleanest teams out there, I doubt you'd consider them "folk".

"Folk" is an attempt at describing a style, which is subjective and semi-arbitrary. "Clean" is a measure of an absolute - unrelated to what the movement is.

i think the statement works, but only one way. a "folk" team is most likely very clean, but a "clean" team is not at all required to be folk
ah amen I can live with that - still don't think clean can be used against anyone since it's a metric, folk can be construed one way or another. but yeah, you're right on that.
 

Jabar Jung

New Member
Messages
926
Im sorry, but why were live teams in the line up? Shouldn't have they been not accepted based on the rubric. Thanks.
 

singhk1

New Member
Messages
416
Sue Sylvester said:
faizan said:
"too folk" really just means: "too boring for our competition"

"not folk enough" really just means: "too exciting for our competition"

:p

+1

thats based on judges and the competition, folk bhangra is not at all boring to watch its amazing
 

singhk1

New Member
Messages
416
Kartik said:
desi99 said:
"too folk" also means "too clean"


good stuff virsa
Not at all; Empire's considered one of the cleanest teams out there, I doubt you'd consider them "folk".

"Folk" is an attempt at describing a style, which is subjective and semi-arbitrary. "Clean" is a measure of an absolute - unrelated to what the movement is.

what do u mean its an attempt, Theres no more "attempting" to describe a style of bhangra like Folk.. thats how bhangra was originated folk its the root of bhangra
 

sangeensingh

Member
Messages
717
singhk1 said:
Kartik said:
desi99 said:
"too folk" also means "too clean"


good stuff virsa
Not at all; Empire's considered one of the cleanest teams out there, I doubt you'd consider them "folk".

"Folk" is an attempt at describing a style, which is subjective and semi-arbitrary. "Clean" is a measure of an absolute - unrelated to what the movement is.

what do u mean its an attempt, Theres no more "attempting" to describe a style of bhangra like Folk.. thats how bhangra was originated folk its the root of bhangra
I agree with Singha over here, the term folk shouldn't be considered a "style" so to speak, as the term folk should refer to how Bhangra originally was done (and some will argue how it still should be done),but this is just my opinion. As Bhangra progressed over the years and teams started to add their own flavors to Bhangra, teams that performed "modern" sets as opposed to "folk" sets made it so that the term "folk" is now considered a separate style of Bhangra VS "Modern".

Since these two style's are now integrated into the present scene of Bhangra, the terms "folk" and "modern" are just our terminology to describe sets/performances. But my question is: is "folk" the right word to use to describe this style? Or is "folk" the right word to use to describe how Bhangra originated? Because in my opinion many interpret this word as one or the other, as opposed to understanding the context in which the word is being used, which has been causing a lot of controversy on the forum lately.
 

Kartik

Member
Messages
319
sangeensingh said:
singhk1 said:
Kartik said:
desi99 said:
"too folk" also means "too clean"


good stuff virsa
Not at all; Empire's considered one of the cleanest teams out there, I doubt you'd consider them "folk".

"Folk" is an attempt at describing a style, which is subjective and semi-arbitrary. "Clean" is a measure of an absolute - unrelated to what the movement is.

what do u mean its an attempt, Theres no more "attempting" to describe a style of bhangra like Folk.. thats how bhangra was originated folk its the root of bhangra
I agree with Singha over here, the term folk shouldn't be considered a "style" so to speak, as the term folk should refer to how Bhangra originally was done (and some will argue how it still should be done),but this is just my opinion. As Bhangra progressed over the years and teams started to add their own flavors to Bhangra, teams that performed "modern" sets as opposed to "folk" sets made it so that the term "folk" is now considered a separate style of Bhangra VS "Modern".

Since these two style's are now integrated into the present scene of Bhangra, the terms "folk" and "modern" are just our terminology to describe sets/performances. But my question is: is "folk" the right word to use to describe this style? Or is "folk" the right word to use to describe how Bhangra originated? Because in my opinion many interpret this word as one or the other, as opposed to understanding the context in which the word is being used, which has been causing a lot of controversy on the forum lately.
... "folk" is used to describe a style. It is a completely subjective term that is applied to characterize a performance. The reason why it is not an absolute is because there is no universally accepted definition of it. You can say it means "closer to the roots of bhangra" but each individual has a different perspective of which set is folk and which isn't (see the ridiculous thread about co-ed teams being ultra-modern - many people say collegiate teams are more "folk", others say toronto teams are more "folk", others say only live teams are "folk"). This is very different from clean, almost everyone can agree what is clean and what isn't.

If you would like to define "folk" as "traditional", which appears to be the case, you should stick to that and not try to expand the definition. As Gabbah Shareef has pointed out 1000 times, the current bhangra performances are so far from "the roots" that it's hilarious to call one type of execution or set more traditional than another. If you want to use "folk" in this definition, the only teams that are folk are ones that perform on dhol way back. Beyond examining if a team does traditional moves, that almost all teams do now, it's silly to compare teams on this standard of traditionality/folkness.

I have zero desire to discuss the modern vs. folk debate, my point is that the people that say "folk should be defined as being close to the roots" are the same people that say "DAMN ABC AEG SGPD ARE SO FOLK" - either be consistent or use a different word. Stop using the pretense of origins, roots, tradition, and "folk", to justify what you find to be the most aesthetically pleasing performances.
 

J-Skeet

New Member
Messages
252
Kartik said:

I have zero desire to discuss the modern vs. folk debate, my point is that the people that say "folk should be defined as being close to the roots" are the same people that say "DAMN ABC AEG SGPD ARE SO FOLK" - either be consistent or use a different word. Stop using the pretense of origins, roots, tradition, and "folk", to justify what you find to be the most aesthetically pleasing performances.
^^^^^ All these weird newbies that came out of nowhere. Just summed up exactly how I feel about them.
 

singhk1

New Member
Messages
416
Kartik said:
sangeensingh said:
singhk1 said:
Kartik said:
desi99 said:
"too folk" also means "too clean"


good stuff virsa
Not at all; Empire's considered one of the cleanest teams out there, I doubt you'd consider them "folk".

"Folk" is an attempt at describing a style, which is subjective and semi-arbitrary. "Clean" is a measure of an absolute - unrelated to what the movement is.

what do u mean its an attempt, Theres no more "attempting" to describe a style of bhangra like Folk.. thats how bhangra was originated folk its the root of bhangra
I agree with Singha over here, the term folk shouldn't be considered a "style" so to speak, as the term folk should refer to how Bhangra originally was done (and some will argue how it still should be done),but this is just my opinion. As Bhangra progressed over the years and teams started to add their own flavors to Bhangra, teams that performed "modern" sets as opposed to "folk" sets made it so that the term "folk" is now considered a separate style of Bhangra VS "Modern".

Since these two style's are now integrated into the present scene of Bhangra, the terms "folk" and "modern" are just our terminology to describe sets/performances. But my question is: is "folk" the right word to use to describe this style? Or is "folk" the right word to use to describe how Bhangra originated? Because in my opinion many interpret this word as one or the other, as opposed to understanding the context in which the word is being used, which has been causing a lot of controversy on the forum lately.
... "folk" is used to describe a style. It is a completely subjective term that is applied to characterize a performance. The reason why it is not an absolute is because there is no universally accepted definition of it. You can say it means "closer to the roots of bhangra" but each individual has a different perspective of which set is folk and which isn't (see the ridiculous thread about co-ed teams being ultra-modern - many people say collegiate teams are more "folk", others say toronto teams are more "folk", others say only live teams are "folk"). This is very different from clean, almost everyone can agree what is clean and what isn't.

If you would like to define "folk" as "traditional", which appears to be the case, you should stick to that and not try to expand the definition. As Gabbah Shareef has pointed out 1000 times, the current bhangra performances are so far from "the roots" that it's hilarious to call one type of execution or set more traditional than another. If you want to use "folk" in this definition, the only teams that are folk are ones that perform on dhol way back. Beyond examining if a team does traditional moves, that almost all teams do now, it's silly to compare teams on this standard of traditionality/folkness.

I have zero desire to discuss the modern vs. folk debate, my point is that the people that say "folk should be defined as being close to the roots" are the same people that say "DAMN ABC AEG SGPD ARE SO FOLK" - either be consistent or use a different word. Stop using the pretense of origins, roots, tradition, and "folk", to justify what you find to be the most aesthetically pleasing performances.

I honestly could not disagree more and I'm not even going to ellaborate on that because you clearly don't know a thing about traditional folk bhangra...If your directing that to me I never once said ABC AEG SGPD are folk because they are not. They are all talented however amd theres no universal definition of it because of the simple fact of the different cultures in the circuit that clearly have different ideas about how bhangra should look. In the modern day circuit All the teams are basically modern at some extent and its 2012 so its bond to happen but the traditional aspect is also seen in a lot of them. I'm not going to get into that either because a topic like that is un debatable because people have there own ideas on how bhangra should look
 

singhk1

New Member
Messages
416
J-Skeet said:
Kartik said:

I have zero desire to discuss the modern vs. folk debate, my point is that the people that say "folk should be defined as being close to the roots" are the same people that say "DAMN ABC AEG SGPD ARE SO FOLK" - either be consistent or use a different word. Stop using the pretense of origins, roots, tradition, and "folk", to justify what you find to be the most aesthetically pleasing performances.
^^^^^ All these weird newbies that came out of nowhere

...you were once a newbie that cme out of no where to so relax Idk who you're calling weird
 

Sue Sylvester

kinnell
Messages
467
singhk1 said:
I honestly could not disagree more and I'm not even going to ellaborate on that because you clearly don't know a thing about traditional folk bhangra...If your directing that to me I never once said ABC AEG SGPD are folk because they are not. theres no universal definition of it because of the simple fact of the different cultures in the circuit that clearly have different ideas about how bhangra should look. In the modern day circuit (north american bhangra) there all modernized teams but a handful of them still have a bunch of Traditional Folk sets for example NJ at big apple and even virsa at tdot... I'm not going to get into that either because a topic like that is un debatable because people have there own minds
Damn, singhk1 or Karan Singh (as your profile would reveal), you would really agree with the opinions of Karan P Singh. In fact, you guys even karma each other up. And you're both from New York! And in the army!! Golly gee wilikers, what a coinkidink! :)
 

Kartik

Member
Messages
319
Singhk1 - I'm sorry that you find my knowledge of traditional folk bhangra inferior. That being said, you may want to re-evaluate some of your positions by exploring the topic in further depth. Like you, I also once had many misconceptions regarding the traditionality of Bhangra. As a freshman, I thought our team was superior to Empire or APD because we did something more "folk". I wanted to believe this very badly because it gives you a sense of entitlement. The more I read and learned about bhangra, the more I realized how stupid that thought process was.


A great starting point is to look at the many examples Gibb Schreffler gives in his "Visual History of Bhangra". If you're more interested in the logic and rationale behind my thought process, I'd urge you to review Gibb's comments in the post below:


http://bhangrateamsforum.com/discuss/main-bhangra-discussion/judging-traditionality-in-the-music-category/msg204967/#msg204967


I would highly suggest you do some of your own reading and then getting back to me with your findings. One thing I've found on this forum is that it's often best to have a flexible viewpoint that is based on learning, rather than taking on a rigid stance and attacking another.
 

singhk1

New Member
Messages
416
Sue Sylvester said:
singhk1 said:
I honestly could not disagree more and I'm not even going to ellaborate on that because you clearly don't know a thing about traditional folk bhangra...If your directing that to me I never once said ABC AEG SGPD are folk because they are not. theres no universal definition of it because of the simple fact of the different cultures in the circuit that clearly have different ideas about how bhangra should look. In the modern day circuit (north american bhangra) there all modernized teams but a handful of them still have a bunch of Traditional Folk sets for example NJ at big apple and even virsa at tdot... I'm not going to get into that either because a topic like that is un debatable because people have there own minds
Damn, singhk1 or Karan Singh (as your profile would reveal), you would really agree with the opinions of Karan P Singh. In fact, you guys even karma each other up. And you're both from New York! And in the army!! Golly gee wilikers, what a coinkidink! :)

This guy...relax I gave that account to my cousin said he was having trouble making an account but im not gonna explain myself, we do not karma eachother and I didn't want people to think im a arrogant shit because I'm not, its just kind of hard to not seem like one when people just don't understand someone fully. Everyone has there own ideas on bhangra and honestly I respect that now
 

singhk1

New Member
Messages
416
Kartik said:
Singhk1 - I'm sorry that you find my knowledge of traditional folk bhangra inferior. That being said, you may want to re-evaluate some of your positions by exploring the topic in further depth. Like you, I also once had many misconceptions regarding the traditionality of Bhangra. As a freshman, I thought our team was superior to Empire or APD because we did something more "folk". I wanted to believe this very badly because it gives you a sense of entitlement. The more I read and learned about bhangra, the more I realized how stupid that thought process was.


A great starting point is to look at the many examples Gibb Schreffler gives in his "Visual History of Bhangra". If you're more interested in the logic and rationale behind my thought process, I'd urge you to review Gibb's comments in the post below:


http://bhangrateamsforum.com/discuss/main-bhangra-discussion/judging-traditionality-in-the-music-category/msg204967/#msg204967


I would highly suggest you do some of your own reading and then getting back to me with your findings. One thing I've found on this forum is that it's often best to have a flexible viewpoint that is based on learning, rather than taking on a rigid stance and attacking another.

My intentions at all were not to offend you nor was it too discuss Modern V Folk yet all the things you just said to me I feel its the other way around. I have a flexible viewpoint I'm not taking a rigid stance and attacking any one, That 2nd last comment u posted was directed more towards what sangeen said anyway. I just felt like I needed to say something about your comment on this thread earlier. You just have someone giving you a valid arguement and now it kind of seems like youre making yourself look like the good guy


but bro You're not always right It just seems like you think u know everything. I don't know you so technically I don't know what u do and don't know about traditional bhangra but just based on wat u said it didn't make too much sense.


At this point I realized Everyone has there own preference for bhangra so let it be just let everyone dance and try topping previous performances because at the end of the day that's what its all about. Also I do not need to do any type of research or look at some other guys oppinions about bhangra because I know bhangra
 

yraparla

SwizzeeMusic.com
Messages
2,072
Moderator's Note: Please keep on topic, this thread is about if a competitive bhangra set can be considered 'too folk'. Please focus on the judging aspect, as that's the crux of the thread.

Side note: If you have questions about a member, absolutely report them so we can take a look and sort it out
 

KushK

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,161
J-Skeet said:
Kartik said:

I have zero desire to discuss the modern vs. folk debate, my point is that the people that say "folk should be defined as being close to the roots" are the same people that say "DAMN ABC AEG SGPD ARE SO FOLK" - either be consistent or use a different word. Stop using the pretense of origins, roots, tradition, and "folk", to justify what you find to be the most aesthetically pleasing performances.
^^^^^ All these weird newbies that came out of nowhere
I'm pretty sure you're the Newb homie.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top