• Bhangra discussion is still going strong. Join us in our Facebook group!

    New user registration has been closed (as it was entirely spam). We encourage you to post in our Facebook group, even if it's a followup to an existing thread. BTF will continue to be archived and hosted here - Saleem

Bhangra Showdown Videos

naujawanidotcom

New Member
Messages
22
rsingh88 said:
I would love to work with others to set up at least one more competition in the UK within the next couple of years but one problem that springs to mind is which teams would compete? I'd like for there to be a completely open competition, where both uni and non-uni teams are eligible, but are there many non-uni teams out there who would compete? Let's say we could set up a competition for June/July 2011, would it just be another chance for the same teams to perform their TBS routines?

For next year's showdown, I think it'd be amazing (but probably far too expensive!) to get a team like NJ, VCU, SGPD etc to do an exhibition performance for the UK audience. Seeing them might give the UK audience a better understanding of how traditional bhangra routines can be done to modern tracks and be geuinely entertaining.

Personally, I think for the purposes of competition the audiences for student and non-student teams are quite different. From my experience across comps in the US, Punjab and TBS in the UK, student-only competitions draw a wider audience from different backgrounds, mainly of the student and family variety. Non-student teams pull in a completely mixed bag, although I'm going to hazard a guess that in the UK it would be very male-heavy. There needs to be provision for non-student comps, but I'd think very carefully before mixing the two - not ruling it out, but as an example, from a financial perspective you would not get the incentives/discounts from suppliers and venues that a student-only and non-commercial event would get.
 

naujawanidotcom

New Member
Messages
22
Hand of Godard said:
Can someone explain how the competition was run, beyond your particular gripes about the competition itself (was there a mixer? how much stage time do you get? what was provided to the teams? what wasn't?). In order for a competition like this to succeed, start pointing out what happened (good and bad). Plus, that'd help us people who are in NA understand what is going on. We've all been to comps (some good, some TERRIBLE), so we have experience we can share ideas/suggestions.
There was no real mixer apart from a pre-party at a club a couple of weeks before.

I'm really flogging a dead horse here now and I apologise if it seems like I'm making out that Naujawani.com is all things to all men and women relating to The Bhangra Showdown. We're not. But in many aspects of the competition, we tried to supplement what Imperial Punjabi soc was doing if we thought it necessary. One of the elements that we were particularly interested in was getting competitors into a room together weeks and even months before the event to network. Our earliest attempt was a dinner last Vaisakhi which 3 bhangra teams/Punjabi socs attended. Most of them knew eacxh other and we thought it needed expanding out. Before the summer break, we organised a mixed Sikh soc and Punjabi soc networking event where only one Punjabi soc/bhangra team turned up! We learnt it's probably better not to mix the two, but still only one team showed?!


But more irritating than all of this was an event we organised for mid-December... a bhangra quiz (not as cheesy as it sounds) for all teams who were on the card to compete at the Bhangra Showdown. Two teams tried to make it down on the day, only one made it. Two further teams said students/members would be coming but then didn't show. Five teams ignored the invitation completely and one quite blunt email from a choreo who said they weren't interested. We paid decent money for a venue and had setup a bhangra quiz that we are now taking into individual bhangra team/Punjabi socs instead. Hand of Godard, did you know about this 'mixer'?! If not, ask your soc/team choreo or president why? We're hosting a Punjabi soc/bhangra team network event nearer Easter again here in London... UK students, PM me if you want us to email you about it directly.


P.S. If you're wondering why as a business we are even doing any of this, visit: http://www.nachdapunjab.co.uk/?page_id=2
 

Hand of Godard

New Member
Messages
74
[quote author=naujawanidotcom]

But more irritating than all of this was an event we organised for mid-December... a bhangra quiz (not as cheesy as it sounds) for all teams who were on the card to compete at the Bhangra Showdown. Two teams tried to make it down on the day, only one made it. Two further teams said students/members would be coming but then didn't show. Five teams ignored the invitation completely and one quite blunt email from a choreo who said they weren't interested. We paid decent money for a venue and had setup a bhangra quiz that we are now taking into individual bhangra team/Punjabi socs instead. Hand of Godard, did you know about this 'mixer'?! If not, ask your soc/team choreo or president why? We're hosting a Punjabi soc/bhangra team network event nearer Easter again here in London... UK students, PM me if you want us to email you about it directly.

P.S. If you're wondering why as a business we are even doing any of this, visit: http://www.nachdapunjab.co.uk/?page_id=2
[/quote]

No, I was not made aware of the event. I personally would have been keen to attend. I apologise if mine was one of the teams that ignored the e-mail (or worse still, was rude in their reply).

Though, something to bare in mind going forward is that mid-December may not be the best time to host such an event for students if only because of people going home/on holiday during the semester break. For example 3 of my team (including myself) are not even from the UK; a fair number of the remainder are not from London and a few who stay at halls aren't allowed to remain there during breaks. A couple are just idiots and have this "us vs them mentality" that would have made them unwilling to attend. Of course, they still could have made the effort but for the reasons stated, with the further complication of exams in the first week of semester for some, I can imagine why they wouldn't have wanted to do so.

In the UK, I suppose we're fortunate that we're close enough geographically that larger events like dinners spaced throughout the school year make sense to at least attempt to organise. But it looks like they're doomed to fail if the teams aren't bonded enough to begin with. In North America, competitions generally have mixers the day before the show. I'm not sure if that's feasible here as it will force some teams to look for/be provided with accommodation and whatnot, but I think it would help the bonding process a bit more and would probably encourage "reunions" at more formal events later in the year.
 

faysal

New Member
Messages
889
its always going to be awkward organising another competition here a) because most independent teams have between 4-8 members other than the older ones like nachda sansaar, jugnu, 4x4 etc but then it would be a case of would you include such teams in the competition? or make them judges and allow for younger generation independent teams to compete instead? I think this idea that many people seem to be stuck on that its only students who should be dancing is a little unfair to those who still dance after they finish their studies. The dancing scene will not grow fast enough here if its restricted to student shows/events. Most of us don't actually gain the knowledge/experience and real passion for dancing until after we finish studying. It's a matter of everyone coming together and helping each other rather than (as hand of godard mentioned above) this us vs them mentality. People really need to let go of their arrogance and unwillingness to learn and help each other, thats the only way things are going to improve over here. How that is to be done is another thing altogether, but whatever anyone comes up with I'd be more than happy to get involved/help.
 

sahibmc

Member
Messages
37
Individual Judges Totals

Birmingham
Brunel
Imperial
King's
Kingston
Leicester+DMU
Manchester
QM
St. Georges
UCL + LSE

Judge 1
46
56
73
43
53
35
40
48
52
-25

Judge 2
84
82
80
71
75
53
57
75
68
25

Judge 3
93
90
91
81
84
53
29
65
76
21

Judge 4
83
83
88
64
82
52
46
72
74
21

Judge 5
97
94
98
74
89
81
30
80
98
23




Average of 3 Middle Judges

Birmingham Brunel Imperial King's Kingston Leicester+DMU Manchester QM St. Georges UCL + LSE
86.67 85.00 86.33 69.67 80.33 52.67 38.67 70.67 72.67 21.67




Overall Rankings

1st Place Birmingham
2nd Place Imperial
3rd Place Brunel
4th Place Kingston
5th Place St. Georges
6th Place QM
7th Place King's
8th Place Leicester+DMU
9th Place Manchester
10th Place UCL+LSE
 

Arjun Barua

Member
Messages
650
Can someone give us an idea of what the judges were looking for? Were they following a scoring rubric? Can't imagine that they were... These scores are all over the place!
 

dheerja

Member
Messages
607
Wow just read through this entire thread and it's pretty eye-opening, great to see so many UK bhangra folks actively posting on BTF - please continue to contribute outside of this thread as well!

The general vibe I'm getting from reading the UK posts is that there are obviously a ton of roadblocks to improving the scene - team interest, more competition organizers, general public image of bhangra, dates for competitions, etc. just to name a few. The beauty of BTF is that we can have these discussions and it's great that you're finally airing out your concerns, but the most important thing is to actually generate something tangible from all this.

Believe it or not, North American bhangra started out in a similar boat wayyy back when. It's easy for us to forget since it's been so long, but Bhangra Blowout was your Punjabi Showdown - university run, the only competition around, and extremely modern and crowd friendly. I'm pretty sure one of the first Blowouts had a team that broke down intro track suits and break danced. The UK scene is just starting to grow, so it's unfair and disheartening to yourselves to compare it to the current North American scene. Our scene has been 18+ years in the making!

So instead of only thinking about the roadblocks and getting frustrated, start with some basic actionable items:

1) Form a committee with an eventual competition in mind. In North America all the original competitions started out with a South Asian organization already established at a school. A lot of you are representing schools on here, so look into getting in touch with your larger organization or forming your own. It can start at your school so you can get the necessary support, but also include those not in uni.

2) Once you've got a solid group of people who are interested in making this happen, start talking hard logistics. Naujawani on this forum seems to be extremely helpful and clearly wants to help make this happen, so reach out to organizations like them that can help.


Do this before you start worrying about venues, getting the Punjabi crowd interested in the show, getting teams to come because of exam schedules, etc. Get to the basics first and figure out the rest. The only way Punjabi Showdown will improve what they're doing (treating teams well, fixing the judging, etc.) is if there's another competition out there. Otherwise what's their incentive?


I know all of this is obvious but if there's anything I've learned it's that we tend to lose sight of the basics when we get caught up in worrying about all the reasons why something is impossible.
 

Hand of Godard

New Member
Messages
74
The judges were:

"Male Bhangra Judge" - Deepak Drubhra of Jugnu
"Female Bhangra Judge" - Veena Jain of the Performing Arts School "Storm Entertainments"
"Industry Judge" - Sunil Kalyan (musician)
"Celebrity Judge" - Bee2
"Non-Bhangra Judge" - Antonio Susinni (described as "a leading internationally established choreographer and dancer who has years of experience in a wide variety of dance styles...currently a teacher at the renowned Pineapple Dance Studios")
 

Vic

Member
Messages
291
they were missing the judge who should have been called "educated in bhangra judge" lol
 

sahibmc

Member
Messages
37
Vic said:
they were missing the judge who should have been called "educated in bhangra judge" lol

BTF should have a LIKE option like on facebook.... I like this VIC lol
 

naujawanidotcom

New Member
Messages
22
Take a look at the Judges scorecard above. Did Judge 1 have a different mark scheme? Seriously. My maths has deteriorated since A levels so someone help me with the terminology... that particular judge is tens of points away from every other judge for every team. I'm not sure what impact that would have on the overall winner, but it should be looked at from the point of view of why that type of judge was selected - whoever it was they were in a different world to everyone else. Maybe they were the good judge and everyone else was bad?!
 

faysal

New Member
Messages
889
if you look at the rubric, the placings start to make slightly more sense. Biggest points for transitions sync fluidity formations execution....of what? well that doesn't really matter since those win you the most points, traditionality is a mere 10 :s
 

nitinchand

New Member
Messages
16
Vic said:
they were missing the judge who should have been called "educated in bhangra judge" lol
couldn't have put it better myself.

BTF - can we PLEASE get somebody to asses these videos (i know its tedious going through them!) and let us know personally what you really think?

If anybody would like to go through them and asses them, i can email you a mark scheme just PM me, or even better - if you've done judging in a decent bhangra competition then please use the one from there/make your own? anything, just as long as we have a decent opinion as to what a bhangra judge would have given the competition (no matter how poor you think it is - it's still all relative).

Personally, I feel that some teams were at the wrong competition. the ''shit interpretations of bhangra empire'' showdown was on the sunday...
 

Hand of Godard

New Member
Messages
74
I don't understand why you have such a low mark, Nitin. Did you lose a lot of points when the girl fell? Or was there a penalty of some sort?
 

ASHKE!

New Member
Messages
1
Hey everyone!


(My 1st post on BTF so I'll try and keep it as short as possible!)


I'm from the QM team and firstly just wanna say a huge well done to everyone that took part in the show and an even bigger well done to Imperial Punjabi Soc for organising it! :D


Obviously there are many issues that need to be addressed by IPS that haven't been resolved already.


The most important point that needs to be sorted out is the choice of judges. If the judges are chosen well then the entire competition will have a completely new and fair feel to it. The other little things can be ignored by most of us IF this one major issue is focused on.


One thing that has me really shocked are the scores!! I definitely agree that one of the judges was in a world of his own! And another point we (LPD & ASHKE!) picked up on was that if the highest and lowest mark was not scraped then Imperial would have actually won the competition... :S


So, a really traditional team placed 1st and a completely modern team placed 2nd (who actually, over the average of all 5 judges, won the competition)!! :eek:


With regards to a new competition, should you mix teams with years and years of experience (GPD, 4X4 etc) with uni teams? Would that be classed as a fair competition in terms of stage experience? Or is it fair to say that their styles (traditional) will be similar so it's fair to judge them regardless of how long they've been dancing for? ???
 

kinnell

*Account Deactivated*
Messages
2,159
I just want to throw this out there: The UK bhangra scene situation is grossly overrated. Y'all are on your way, don't cheapen all the progress/improvement your teams made from last year's competition just because you didn't place or get the response you wanted.

After watching the videos, the problem does not seem to be education of the teams. (Perhaps, education of the judges, I could care less about placings). The biggest thing that took away from all of these performances was uncleanliness, messiness and mistakes. Those things take time, not workshops to learn the "true essence of bhangra".

For those currently involved in the UK scene, if you guys practiced year long, you guys would improve tremendously. There is no secret/shortcut that the North American teams have that you guys must learn to do well/better. Keep up what you guys do. If you only have 2 months to train for this competition, then practice smarter. Don't make the choreography difficult if your dancers have difficulty picking it up. (But don't worry, a lot of US teams are guilty of this as well).

For those asking for input on videos, they really aren't as bad as you think they were. As I said, practice harder and practice smarter. Clean wins the game, not choreography. Even if judges are wack, they will be less inclined to dock points if you are flawless on stage.
 

Jas13

Member
Messages
103
I agree with kinnell above, in order for us to get that synchronisity on stage we need to put the practise in, no doubt about it. One thing I would say regarding the judges etc, is during the run up to the show, Imperial were very accomodating to ideas from the various teams that take part. There were 2 choreo's meetings that took place, one last summer and the other a few months after. This is where we ALL discussed the mark scheme and layout of the judges. Each team had atleast one member at the meetings. Some of the views above hint that Imperial messed up, infact looking back in hindsight the choreos messed up in choosing that particular layout of judges. TBS is young, we have all learnt from this and hopefully it'll be rectified for next year.
 

Jas13

Member
Messages
103
Gurnak said:
P.S. Maybe some of the teams could post their mixes??? Sharing is caring!!
Hey guys, here's Birmingham's Mix. Lemme know what you all think, it took me an age to make, lol! Big Up to DJ Harmeet for helping me with the last two tracks! Those beats were needed yaar!
 

Attachments

Top