HeerSaleti408
New Member
- Messages
- 14
Re: **BTF Remix Challenge 2: 2 NyCe (5) vs. H.M.N.I. (3)**
uh B.
uh B.
-
Bhangra discussion is still going strong. Join us in our Facebook group!
New user registration has been closed (as it was entirely spam). We encourage you to post in our Facebook group, even if it's a followup to an existing thread. BTF will continue to be archived and hosted here - Saleem
**BTF Remix Challenge 1: 2 NyCe (5) vs. H.M.N.I. (3)** Winner: 2 NyCe
- Thread starter sangeensingh
- Start date
footballforlife
Don't let the name fool you.
- Messages
- 526
Re: **BTF Remix Challenge 2: 2 NyCe (5) vs. H.M.N.I. (3)**
Track B. Its not too close..
Track B. Its not too close..
Panj_Dariaah
Member
- Messages
- 157
Re: **BTF Remix Challenge 2: 2 NyCe (5) vs. H.M.N.I. (3)**
Track B. Nice mix.
Track B. Nice mix.
hardeep_singh
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 1,463
Re: **BTF Remix Challenge 2: 2 NyCe (5) vs. H.M.N.I. (3)**
Review:
Track A
0:00 - random nonsensical thing, bad way to start a track
0:01-0:05 - "hoye hoye" + punjabi crowd noise loop = messy, not a fan of the crowd noise thing at all never use that
0:07-0:14 - two vocal tracks overlapping with the dhol track goin full blast, sounds bad
0:16-0:19 - there are better ways of transitioning than using a earnumbing gunshot effect
0:19-0:27 - beat is loud, dhol loop sounds on key with the vocals, i see the bhangra potential
0:28.5 - don't know if its intentional but the beat falters slightly for a really short amount of time listen carefully and you'll hear it
0:40 - constant dhol loop gets tiring/boring at this point
0:46-0:56 - dhol loop is officially played out and the "hoys" dont add anything...at all, either use "hoys" sparingly or dont use em at all unless your making a bhangra mix and they coincide with something in the choreo
0:57-1:00 - some random beat box sounding loop in the back, dont like it
1:01 - abrupt transition, no smoothness
1:02 - glass shattering...doesn't help the transition
1:02-1:26 - i like it even though the dhol beat is really freakin loud, doesnt hurt to tone the levels down a bit
1:27-1:39 - speed of loop does not go well with speed of vocals, that dhol loop is way too fast, way too loud ruins the vocal track
1:40-1:42 - "bruah" not a good way to end a track
Track B
0:00-0:13 - don't see the point of keeping the background "techno-ish" loop at a constant level, makes the track seem saturated once the vocal track come in at 0:06
0:14-0:22 - not a fan of the random rap verse, dont feel like it adds anything to the track, especially at 0:20 when the word (im guessing ill) is repeated, just sounds distracting
0:14-0:36 - beats and effects match up well, good use of simple effect at 0:27, i'm listening on $20 headphones and bass level seems kinda high
0:36-0:40 - bass + hek at 0:38 clash alot, i wouldnt say it sounds distorted but it doesnt sound clean, might be cuz im listening on headphones
0:41-0:43 - i like the windup, dont like the air horn, air horn effect needs to die, at least its not excessively loud
0:53-1:07 - slow algozay and dhad track, fast beat track, fast rap vocal, doesnt sound bad but doesnt sound clean either, you could take out the algozay part and keep it fast or slow down the beat and use a slow rap verse, which might sound better since the track transitions into a slow segment 1:00-1:01 i like the effect
1:08-1:33 - the synth effect loop thing that continues through this segment is kinda distracting, would sound better without it, 1:11-1:13 i like whats done with the air horn but i still dont like the airhorn, maybe try to do the same with a fresher sounding effect
1:37 - good wind up and drop, but not feeling the opera track, dont like the opera ending, i think it would sound sick if you had a fast high pitch keyboard/piano track that matched up and faded out at the end
My vote is for Track B, can't imagine doin bhangra to it but it's cleaner and more original than Track A.
Review:
Track A
0:00 - random nonsensical thing, bad way to start a track
0:01-0:05 - "hoye hoye" + punjabi crowd noise loop = messy, not a fan of the crowd noise thing at all never use that
0:07-0:14 - two vocal tracks overlapping with the dhol track goin full blast, sounds bad
0:16-0:19 - there are better ways of transitioning than using a earnumbing gunshot effect
0:19-0:27 - beat is loud, dhol loop sounds on key with the vocals, i see the bhangra potential
0:28.5 - don't know if its intentional but the beat falters slightly for a really short amount of time listen carefully and you'll hear it
0:40 - constant dhol loop gets tiring/boring at this point
0:46-0:56 - dhol loop is officially played out and the "hoys" dont add anything...at all, either use "hoys" sparingly or dont use em at all unless your making a bhangra mix and they coincide with something in the choreo
0:57-1:00 - some random beat box sounding loop in the back, dont like it
1:01 - abrupt transition, no smoothness
1:02 - glass shattering...doesn't help the transition
1:02-1:26 - i like it even though the dhol beat is really freakin loud, doesnt hurt to tone the levels down a bit
1:27-1:39 - speed of loop does not go well with speed of vocals, that dhol loop is way too fast, way too loud ruins the vocal track
1:40-1:42 - "bruah" not a good way to end a track
Track B
0:00-0:13 - don't see the point of keeping the background "techno-ish" loop at a constant level, makes the track seem saturated once the vocal track come in at 0:06
0:14-0:22 - not a fan of the random rap verse, dont feel like it adds anything to the track, especially at 0:20 when the word (im guessing ill) is repeated, just sounds distracting
0:14-0:36 - beats and effects match up well, good use of simple effect at 0:27, i'm listening on $20 headphones and bass level seems kinda high
0:36-0:40 - bass + hek at 0:38 clash alot, i wouldnt say it sounds distorted but it doesnt sound clean, might be cuz im listening on headphones
0:41-0:43 - i like the windup, dont like the air horn, air horn effect needs to die, at least its not excessively loud
0:53-1:07 - slow algozay and dhad track, fast beat track, fast rap vocal, doesnt sound bad but doesnt sound clean either, you could take out the algozay part and keep it fast or slow down the beat and use a slow rap verse, which might sound better since the track transitions into a slow segment 1:00-1:01 i like the effect
1:08-1:33 - the synth effect loop thing that continues through this segment is kinda distracting, would sound better without it, 1:11-1:13 i like whats done with the air horn but i still dont like the airhorn, maybe try to do the same with a fresher sounding effect
1:37 - good wind up and drop, but not feeling the opera track, dont like the opera ending, i think it would sound sick if you had a fast high pitch keyboard/piano track that matched up and faded out at the end
My vote is for Track B, can't imagine doin bhangra to it but it's cleaner and more original than Track A.
sangeensingh
Member
- Messages
- 717
Re: **BTF Remix Challenge 2: 2 NyCe (5) vs. H.M.N.I. (3)**
but anyways, DONT REVEAL THE DAMN IDENTITIES, to still keep the voting fair i request that MODS PLEASE DELETE THOSE COMMENTS! Its only fair.
i didnt know people use winap or whatever to open up music, hahah.GSingh said:
but anyways, DONT REVEAL THE DAMN IDENTITIES, to still keep the voting fair i request that MODS PLEASE DELETE THOSE COMMENTS! Its only fair.
disharma1317
disharmz
- Messages
- 230
Re: **BTF Remix Challenge 2: 2 NyCe (5) vs. H.M.N.I. (3)**
track B
track B
kashkoor15
New Member
- Messages
- 55
Re: **BTF Remix Challenge 2: 2 NyCe (5) vs. H.M.N.I. (3)**
B
B
ENVY BANG-RUH
Let the music move you!!!!!
- Messages
- 1,151
Re: **BTF Remix Challenge 2: 2 NyCe (5) vs. H.M.N.I. (3)**
My vote is for B
My vote is for B
sartajjudge
New Member
- Messages
- 609
Re: **BTF Remix Challenge 2: 2 NyCe (5) vs. H.M.N.I. (3)**
B. Bruuahhhh 2 Nyce!
B. Bruuahhhh 2 Nyce!
harjap_singh
New Member
- Messages
- 234
Re: **BTF Remix Challenge 2: 2 NyCe (5) vs. H.M.N.I. (3)**
B
B