• Bhangra discussion is still going strong. Join us in our Facebook group!

    New user registration has been closed (as it was entirely spam). We encourage you to post in our Facebook group, even if it's a followup to an existing thread. BTF will continue to be archived and hosted here - Saleem

Competition Judges

ENVY BANG-RUH

Let the music move you!!!!!
Messages
1,151
With all this criticizing the committee for picking the judges or the judges for just being horrible. Why not everyone on here who knows damn well who legit good judges are,




Make a list of their names

Which competitons they have judged at (so that we know their qualifications)

What part of the states or canada they're from (NW, SW, NE, SE, west canada, east canada, or where ever else there are good judges)

What type of bhangra they follow suit (traditional w/music, Live, Modern)

IF THEY BELIEVE GIRLS SHOULD DO BHANGRA OR NOT (because i feel, they would probably mark down points for that reason alone, maybe, not sure, if anyone has been through a situation like that, please do share.

AND If they have any sort of relationship with any teams, that way, when it comes to picking judges fairly, there are no family ties or whatever and it'll be a lot fairer (dont know if thats a word)




After a decent list of judges has been put together, maybe one of the admins will be able to add a link in that red link bar (home, btf wiki, profile, etc) with the judges names, and their info that has been given about them.


After all said and done, committees will know where to look for judges.
 

Gugu

New Member
Messages
257
Good idea.

Norcal:
Dr. Manjinder Dhaliwal - judged DDA for 3 years now, and I think Nachda Punjab as well
Pali Singh - Heeray's singer - judged DDA this year, pretty much a bhangra god
HS Bhajan - judged DDA last couple years as well

There's few more I know, and will update when I can remember lol...
 

ajay

New Member
Messages
21
Jaspal singh Khalsa from ajay bhangra acedemy. he been teaching bhangra for more than 15 years. also performed for more than 15 years before teaching.
 

ENVY BANG-RUH

Let the music move you!!!!!
Messages
1,151
where from? style? this is for future posters. As i said before, it'd make things alot easier if we know who is who, where they're from, what experience they have, and what type of bhangra they follow.
 

justAguy

^chilllan w/ AMY GOODMAN in my pic wooo im famous^
Messages
284
ajay said:
Jaspal singh Khalsa from ajay bhangra acedemy. he been teaching bhangra for more than 15 years. also performed for more than 15 years before teaching.
I don't think bhangras been around for 30 years ...
 

COMTONDAJATT

mint gumri
Messages
302
justAguy said:
ajay said:
Jaspal singh Khalsa from ajay bhangra acedemy. he been teaching bhangra for more than 15 years. also performed for more than 15 years before teaching.
I don't think bhangras been around for 30 years ...
People have been dancing on stage since around '49 so it is plausible.
 

Jabar Jung

New Member
Messages
926
Stage Bhangra has been around for a long time.

1) Shri Narinder Pandit- 6 or 7 (not really sure) times best dancer Dav college jallandhar, that was like in the early 70s, proper traditional dhol judge. East Coast.
2) Sardar Jarnail Singh dholi- Played dhol with teams in India, teaches bhangra and dhol, Proper traditional bhangra judge. East Coast.
3) I am not sure about the name, but he is Nana the dholis dad, heard he is also a proper traditional judge. East Coast.
4) I believe surmeet and benny can qualify to judge traditional judges also. East Coast.

if i find more i'll add to the list.
 

justAguy

^chilllan w/ AMY GOODMAN in my pic wooo im famous^
Messages
284
COMTONDAJATT said:
justAguy said:
ajay said:
Jaspal singh Khalsa from ajay bhangra acedemy. he been teaching bhangra for more than 15 years. also performed for more than 15 years before teaching.
I don't think bhangras been around for 30 years ...
People have been dancing on stage since around '49 so it is plausible.
Yeah but I highly doubt it's even close to how it's done today. I'm pretty sure the whole 'traditional' mindset and choregraphy has been fabricated within the last 15 years if not less
 

COMTONDAJATT

mint gumri
Messages
302
justAguy said:
COMTONDAJATT said:
justAguy said:
ajay said:
Jaspal singh Khalsa from ajay bhangra acedemy. he been teaching bhangra for more than 15 years. also performed for more than 15 years before teaching.
I don't think bhangras been around for 30 years ...
People have been dancing on stage since around '49 so it is plausible.
Yeah but I highly doubt it's even close to how it's done today. I'm pretty sure the whole 'traditional' mindset and choregraphy has been fabricated within the last 15 years if not less
Oh yea in that respect you have a point. The kind of stage dance we see now in Punjab I don't remember seeing in the mid 90s.
 

ajay

New Member
Messages
21
justAguy said:
COMTONDAJATT said:
justAguy said:
ajay said:
Jaspal singh Khalsa from ajay bhangra acedemy. he been teaching bhangra for more than 15 years. also performed for more than 15 years before teaching.
I don't think bhangras been around for 30 years ...
People have been dancing on stage since around '49 so it is plausible.
Yeah but I highly doubt it's even close to how it's done today. I'm pretty sure the whole 'traditional' mindset and choregraphy has been fabricated within the last 15 years if not less
I see your point but this guy teaches lil kids till they go out to colleges. His students are/were in gabroo shookeen, empire, empire jrs, etc he's well respected at all the melas in bay area. bhangra has changed but they know how to keep themselves up with it after all they love it. bhangra been around for more than you guys think. please if you do bhangra should learn about its history too.
 

manmeet

New Member
Messages
30
ajay said:
justAguy said:
COMTONDAJATT said:
justAguy said:
ajay said:
Jaspal singh Khalsa from ajay bhangra acedemy. he been teaching bhangra for more than 15 years. also performed for more than 15 years before teaching.
I don't think bhangras been around for 30 years ...
People have been dancing on stage since around '49 so it is plausible.
Yeah but I highly doubt it's even close to how it's done today. I'm pretty sure the whole 'traditional' mindset and choregraphy has been fabricated within the last 15 years if not less
I see your point but this guy teaches lil kids till they go out to colleges. His students are/were in gabroo shookeen, empire, empire jrs, etc he's well respected at all the melas in bay area. bhangra has changed but they know how to keep themselves up with it after all they love it. bhangra been around for more than you guys think. please if you do bhangra should learn about its history too.
great job defending your dad..ajay....
 

blanca_c

New Member
Messages
69
Good idea

Also:

ENVY BANG-RUH said:
IF THEY BELIEVE GIRLS SHOULD DO BHANGRA OR NOT (because i feel, they would probably mark down points for that reason alone, maybe, not sure, if anyone has been through a situation like that, please do share.
I was wondering about this! Don't think I've experienced this, but I'm curious to know if anyone has.

No suggestions for now, will definitely post if I hear/think of something.
 

MPElive

Ehhh Folllkkkkkk Ahhh !!
Messages
323
blanca_c said:
I was wondering about this! Don't think I've experienced this, but I'm curious to know if anyone has.

No suggestions for now, will definitely post if I hear/think of something.
Blanca, I don't think you will ever experience this unless you come across a judge straight from India or go to more traditional competitions, mainly n Canada.
 

ENVY BANG-RUH

Let the music move you!!!!!
Messages
1,151
Going back and looking at my original post now, i realized i made some fucked up gramatical errors. Hooked on Fonix dun Me Gud
 

kinnell

*Account Deactivated*
Messages
2,159
Bharatnatyam teachers and professors of Anthropology make the best bhangra judges. No bias for or against any team - you cannot beat that level of fairness!
 

dheerja

Member
Messages
607
MPElive said:
blanca_c said:
I was wondering about this! Don't think I've experienced this, but I'm curious to know if anyone has.

No suggestions for now, will definitely post if I hear/think of something.
Blanca, I don't think you will ever experience this unless you come across a judge straight from India or go to more traditional competitions, mainly n Canada.
Actually Atinder I've heard this from a judge who's been pretty prominent in the East Coast circuit, Teginder Dhanoa. It was a while ago, in 2005 I believe, so maybe his views have changed but it was pretty upsetting.
 
Top