• Bhangra discussion is still going strong. Join us in our Facebook group!

    New user registration has been closed (as it was entirely spam). We encourage you to post in our Facebook group, even if it's a followup to an existing thread. BTF will continue to be archived and hosted here - Saleem

Elite 8 Bhangra Invitational 2011 - FIRST INVITEE

KushK

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,161
Goodluck to Virsa !!! its going to be one of the best weekends of your lives! haha.. shoutouts to Gary, Dupi, and Sunny.. DO IT BIG BOYS! 8)
 

crimsonNcream

New Member
Messages
81
Even though its Elite 8, what about having the elite 8 + Returning Champion? That way the region from wherever the returning champ comes from can have 2 representatives and also soem more variety in the lineup?


have not really thought this through but just wanted to throw that idea out there
 

Vijay

Member
Messages
646
how do we know that SMD wasnt invited but for w/e reason turned down the offer? always a possibility. also, nikhil brings up a very solid point in that it may not only be about the placings of a team and the amount one has competed, but also what they have done to promote bhangra at large. ie- BAB by virsa, one hell of a competition that actually went well in nyc + their jr squads (folksters, ckfa), etc
 

ranjit singh

New Member
Messages
308
HarmanSingh said:
faizan said:
smd should have been the pick for sure, they have placed like 4-5 times this season...oh well...already heard which teams got in, last year's line up was better...

Last year Duniya and LBC hardly ever competed, did not place anywhere (I think) but were still selected. Also, I would not consider Empire to be anywhere near the level of the elite teams in dancing ability (and were clearly outmatched in every regard at Elite 8 ), they were more so selected on influence.
word
 

Ashveer

New Member
Messages
492
Nikhil said:
Maybe it's beyond what the team does on the stage or its track record for placements and wins at the competition. We can see that with Empire last year, it was an automatic bid because of the outreach it had and the fact that the team made Bhangra BLOWUP.
What Empire did on stage was appreciated by fans (type in "bhangra" on youtube) if not by the standards of what BTF-ideology about bhangra is; the team had just come off of a sweep of Boston/BOB/VIBC/Bruin in '09. At that time of selection the only mega-famous thing that was done was visit 1 to the white house. I'm not writing in reaction of using Empire as an example, but I'm confused about your point. Would the same understand apply if KJ were selected on the grounds of influence in the circuit?

Big ups to Virsa, Elite is a fun comp that is very well organized with a brilliant and committed staff...Good luck!
 

Nikhil

New Member
Messages
881
Ashveer said:
Nikhil said:
Maybe it's beyond what the team does on the stage or its track record for placements and wins at the competition. We can see that with Empire last year, it was an automatic bid because of the outreach it had and the fact that the team made Bhangra BLOWUP.

What Empire did on stage was appreciated by fans (type in "bhangra" on youtube) if not by the standards of what BTF-ideology about bhangra is; the team had just come off of a sweep of Boston/BOB/VIBC/Bruin in '09. At that time of selection the only mega-famous thing that was done was visit 1 to the white house. I'm not writing in reaction of using Empire as an example, but I'm confused about your point. Would the same understand apply if KJ were selected on the grounds of influence in the circuit?

Big ups to Virsa, Elite is a fun comp that is very well organized with a brilliant and committed staff...Good luck!
I should have clarified what I meant Ashveer. The reason I said maybe it's more than the track record of wins and placements is because of how much good you did the community BY going to the White House. Of course the straight wins in that time period was the basis for being elite, but in addition to that, I was trying to make the point that Empire went above and beyond what any team did (that was invited). The comment had nothing to do with appreciation of the dance by the fans; I just didn't mention it because it was obvious! hahaha

You guys had the invite in the bag when everyone knew you went to the WH. This, in my opinion is better than any first place.
 

kinnell

*Account Deactivated*
Messages
2,159
Performing/exhibited at exclusive venues (White House, United Nations, America's Got Talent, Hulu.com, Olympics, Documentaries) is one thing, but throwing a competition, no matter how great a competition like Big Apple Bhangra, doesn't really translate into how well a team would perform on your stage. I don't understand how that can even be a factor in the decision because at the end of the day, the teams are judged on performances, not how much community service they have done or how well they are able to manage events. Taking bhangra to new levels by performing at bigger and better venues makes sense since there the team's performances have had to have reached a certain caliber to be invited/reached out to.


Honestly, if throwing-a-competition was a factor, then Boston Bhangra simply needs to go out there, compete/place 2-3 times this coming year. They do have a junior's team and they were quite influential in the Boston and MA area for the last 8 years or so. They might have been slightly MIA in the last 1-2 years, but they have competed here and there and have a strong history of placings/winning in the past. Boston Bhangra Competition has been the most successful east coast competition for the past few years too.


Honestly, I hope that this really wasn't a factor and Virsa got it based on the merit of their performances and their performances from the past. Virsa has been around for much longer than SMD, has competed more (15 competitions with collabs) and has more trophies (10 trophies). Perhaps beating out an Elite 8 team at Masti (SGPD) also helped their chances.
 

Nikhil

New Member
Messages
881
Kinnell, I think it's as simple as seeing that a team can do well at a number of competitions, and make a name for itself outside of a competition. The selection of one team amongst several teams who can do all of that, shows that the quality of the performances and how well the off-stage events were must have been better than other teams up for consideration.
 

Ashveer

New Member
Messages
492
Nikhil said:
Ashveer said:
Nikhil said:
Maybe it's beyond what the team does on the stage or its track record for placements and wins at the competition. We can see that with Empire last year, it was an automatic bid because of the outreach it had and the fact that the team made Bhangra BLOWUP.

What Empire did on stage was appreciated by fans (type in "bhangra" on youtube) if not by the standards of what BTF-ideology about bhangra is; the team had just come off of a sweep of Boston/BOB/VIBC/Bruin in '09. At that time of selection the only mega-famous thing that was done was visit 1 to the white house. I'm not writing in reaction of using Empire as an example, but I'm confused about your point. Would the same understand apply if KJ were selected on the grounds of influence in the circuit?

Big ups to Virsa, Elite is a fun comp that is very well organized with a brilliant and committed staff...Good luck!
I should have clarified what I meant Ashveer. The reason I said maybe it's more than the track record of wins and placements is because of how much good you did the community BY going to the White House. Of course the straight wins in that time period was the basis for being elite, but in addition to that, I was trying to make the point that Empire went above and beyond what any team did (that was invited). The comment had nothing to do with appreciation of the dance by the fans; I just didn't mention it because it was obvious! hahaha

You guys had the invite in the bag when everyone knew you went to the WH. This, in my opinion is better than any first place.
fshooooo
 

Vic

Member
Messages
291
In my opinion, Virsa deserves this as much as any other team. Simply put, they have the talent and the capabilities to bring it hard to the competition. There is a reason why they were chosen over other teams, and I think the reason is in relation to being a talented group of guys and being able to put great routines on stage.
 

Saleem

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
1,928
Vic, not to beat this to death but let's suppose E8 picks NJ and Shan-E from Canada East. Would you say that they are a "talented group of guys and [are] able to put great routines on stage." or would you say SGPD has competed more widely and more successfully than Shan-E Punjab?
 

HarmanSingh

New Member
Messages
531
Saleem said:
Vic, not to beat this to death but let's suppose E8 picks NJ and Shan-E from Canada East. Would you say that they are a "talented group of guys and [are] able to put great routines on stage." or would you say SGPD has competed more widely and more successfully than Shan-E Punjab?
Based on what Toronto does, every Punjabi in Toronto would grab a machete and baseball bat to go settle this like men. After all, this is dancing. Nothing is more serious.
 

Rajbir

New Member
Messages
322
HarmanSingh said:
Saleem said:
Vic, not to beat this to death but let's suppose E8 picks NJ and Shan-E from Canada East. Would you say that they are a "talented group of guys and [are] able to put great routines on stage." or would you say SGPD has competed more widely and more successfully than Shan-E Punjab?
Based on what Toronto does, every Punjabi in Toronto would grab a machete and baseball bat to go settle this like men. After all, this is dancing. Nothing is more serious.
your soo cool.
 
Top