• Bhangra discussion is still going strong. Join us in our Facebook group!

    New user registration has been closed (as it was entirely spam). We encourage you to post in our Facebook group, even if it's a followup to an existing thread. BTF will continue to be archived and hosted here - Saleem

Elite 8 - Review

Bhangra Critic

New Member
Messages
57
Overall a great event and amazing performances. I've watched all the videos and each team was exciting and in no way was this elite 8 not as good, if not better, than the previous two. After watching each video, and giving actual thought, I seriously believe NYPD won this competition. I thought since I'm a fan of "Toronto Bhangra" was I just not giving UNC a chance?


But, then I thought when I watch a bhangra routine i look for energy, cleanness, nakhra, and something new, especially at Elite 8 since many people look at it as the biggest competition of the year. So when I compared the two there was no doubt that UNC was much cleaner, but at the same time the energy level (pace) of the routine and creativity was much greater for NYPD.


Now at the same time JJ and AEG could be put in that argument but why UNC and NYPD separated themselves from the other 6 was because of how they utilized those aspects so well throughout their whole routine. Honestly, i didnt know UNC and my mistake they really surprised me and I do understand why they could have made the judges give them the win, but in my opinion and the way i judge a performance I give NYPD the win.


This was just my opinion and it will differ from others, but both UNC and NYPD keep it up, I probably would even have een surprised if they had the first ever elite 8 tie. Quick note, NYPD gimmicks did compliment the routine and did flow, maybe some people should watch the video again..
 

Sue Sylvester

kinnell
Messages
467
Amazing competition. I have a few thoughts that I might share later but honestly, almost every team brought it.

Deepi253 said:
aeg - way too much going on sloppy at many times ... intresting to watch but nothing new from old sets that made me go wowowowow ... sorry?
No need to apologize! We appreciate the honesty, Deepi. It's easy to forget that for teams that compete 4-5 times a year, it's harder to change up the entire choreography every single time. We still did, just for you, and got to try out a few new concepts but one or two of our x-factors were bound to return. :)
 

faizan

Just shut up and dance
Messages
1,736
my rankings:


1. nypd
2. jj
3. unc
4. smd
5. aeg
6. bk
7. apd
8. vcu
 

Reeeeda

Member
Messages
71
Figured I would chime in here and express how impressed I am with Elite 8.

I have attended the show every single year since it started and this year I was lucky enough to perform. Every year, the show is always phenomenal, but this year, I got to experience how great Elite 8 is both backstage and from the audience. It was extremely refreshing to have everything running on time, all meals provided (loved the chipotle for dinner on Friday night!!) and to always be informed of what was going on.

Of all the competitions I have been to, this is the most organized and well run. The mixer was legit and very unique and I give Emdo much respect for being creative. Majority agrees that this show and the teams that came brought Elite 8 and bhangra in general to a whole new level.

I sincerely hope Emdo is proud of themselves. So much criticism was thrown at them about teams dropping and some even questioned Elite 8 as a competition, speculating that teams may be dropping because of how Elite was run and questioning how three huge names could just drop out of one of the most prestigious competitions around. Although we would have loved to see SGPD, NJ and PCBCA, i personally didn't feel their absence during the show.

Not going through every single team, but I do have some honorable mentions:

NYPD - You guys blew my mind. My jaw was literally dropped. Wouldve given you guys the title.
JJ - Jhoomer was so sick. Yellow Jodi (especially Sheel) and shorter blue guy had my attention the whole time - they stuck out above all. I mentioned this to someone else and I will say it again - JJ has such an impressive roster of dancers...strongest roster of the night in my opinion.
UNC - our dressing room was right next to them. And I have to say, this team was one of the most humble I have ever come across. I spoke to someone on UNC after they won and was curious to how the reach their level of cleanliness... his reply: 'its all our captains... they did this. It was all their hard work and drilling'. Didn't catch your name, but I really respect you for the answer you gave. So happy for you guys... never lose your modesty.

After party was awesome. Very spacious and def a good venue choice.

Fire alarm at the hotel was a bit annoying and I really do feel bad for the e8 committee for having to deal with that mess among other small mishaps that took place here and there. It was also really annoying to get a knock on the door right when the sun was just about rising saying all the teams needed to leave. This wasn't Elite 8 or Emdo's fault. I hope teams and all those affiliated will begin to display more respect for each other, judges, organizers and committees. They put so much work into making competitions and events successful - the least we could do is respect what they worked so long and hard for.

Again - so so so impressed with EMDO and Elite 8.. expecting even bigger and better things next year. cant really wrap my head around how much better it can get, but I'm confident there will be no disappointments.

Thanks to GMU for letting SMD borrow their kato's and Lavesh for the bag to transport them! You guys are the best!

I had so much fun this weekend - still going through post competition withdrawal.
 

achintchani

New Member
Messages
41
Reeeeda said:
Figured I would chime in here and express how impressed I am with Elite 8.

I have attended the show every single year since it started and this year I was lucky enough to perform. Every year, the show is always phenomenal, but this year, I got to experience how great Elite 8 is both backstage and from the audience. It was extremely refreshing to have everything running on time, all meals provided (loved the chipotle for dinner on Friday night!!) and to always be informed of what was going on.

Of all the competitions I have been to, this is the most organized and well run. The mixer was legit and very unique and I give Emdo much respect for being creative. Majority agrees that this show and the teams that came brought Elite 8 and bhangra in general to a whole new level.

I sincerely hope Emdo is proud of themselves. So much criticism was thrown at them about teams dropping and some even questioned Elite 8 as a competition, speculating that teams may be dropping because of how Elite was run and questioning how three huge names could just drop out of one of the most prestigious competitions around. Although we would have loved to see SGPD, NJ and PCBCA, i personally didn't feel their absence during the show.

Not going through every single team, but I do have some honorable mentions:

NYPD - You guys blew my mind. My jaw was literally dropped. Wouldve given you guys the title.
JJ - Jhoomer was so sick. Yellow Jodi (especially Sheel) and shorter blue guy had my attention the whole time - they stuck out above all. I mentioned this to someone else and I will say it again - JJ has such an impressive roster of dancers...strongest roster of the night in my opinion.
UNC - our dressing room was right next to them. And I have to say, this team was one of the most humble I have ever come across. I spoke to someone on UNC after they won and was curious to how the reach their level of cleanliness... his reply: 'its all our captains... they did this. It was all their hard work and drilling'. Didn't catch your name, but I really respect you for the answer you gave. So happy for you guys... never lose your modesty.

After party was awesome. Very spacious and def a good venue choice.

Fire alarm at the hotel was a bit annoying and I really do feel bad for the e8 committee for having to deal with that mess among other small mishaps that took place here and there. It was also really annoying to get a knock on the door right when the sun was just about rising saying all the teams needed to leave. This wasn't Elite 8 or Emdo's fault. I hope teams and all those affiliated will begin to display more respect for each other, judges, organizers and committees. They put so much work into making competitions and events successful - the least we could do is respect what they worked so long and hard for.

Again - so so so impressed with EMDO and Elite 8.. expecting even bigger and better things next year. cant really wrap my head around how much better it can get, but I'm confident there will be no disappointments.

Thanks to GMU for letting SMD borrow their kato's and Lavesh for the bag to transport them! You guys are the best!

I had so much fun this weekend - still going through post competition withdrawal.
^ +1. Also i would like to thank Nisha, SMD's liaison, for being with us the whole weekend and taking beautiful pictures of us! so sweet of u :)

had an amazing time!
 

Sue Sylvester

kinnell
Messages
467
Preface:
The thing with Elite 8 is that every team goes to DC not just wanting to win, but thinking that they will as well. Every team has an ace up their sleeve and while everyone is still chill with everyone, there's still a serious undertone to everything that is said.

But teams go to Elite 8 for more than just a trophy. Everyone wants to win and everyone thinks they will too, but it's obvious there's more to it as well. Teams want to compete at Elite 8 not only compete against but also compete with the best. We want to come back, trophy or no trophy, and say, "yo dawg, these teams were NASTY, it was awesome sharing the stage with them.". SGPD and NJ not being present was very unfortunate, but to repeat what has been said, their absence was not felt. And honestly, had they been present, I still feel that the results would have been the same with UNC bringing the trophy back to the United States. (Assuming another team dropped for UNC to get the bid).

Elite 8 was an unique competition for me, personally. I was just as involved with AEG in terms of set creation as before, but did not dance, so it allowed me to watch everything unfold in a different way. It definitely allowed me to see a different side of things.

Team Reviews:
Joshiley Jawan: Almost everything was on point. There were a few mistakes, but the execution and formations were amazing. There was ridiculous amount of talent on the team and it definitely showed. Nonetheless, the key players swag too much at times and need to show more control so it doesn't take away from the overall team cleanliness. To say there was no gimmicks in the set and that this is a complete folk set is not correct, but there was a ideal balance between bhangra and creativity.

Shaan Mutiyaaran Di: This was the best all-girl team performance I have seen to date. The new style is better suited for the current circuit and it's good to see you girls come back from Bruin with a strong, clean set. I'm not the biggest fan of the vardii because there's too much embroidery and some of the gimmicks were unnecessary. Overall, a strong showing from SMD and I hope the girls don't lose this momentum.

Anakh E Gabroo: The only thing I will say is that of the guys who danced at Elite 8 2010, 2 years ago, only 1 of them returned to dance this year. I am proud of the dancers who learned a set we created in 3 months.

Bhangra Knights: BK was improving competition by competition as March came closer, but this was definitely a jump in quality of choreography and cleanliness from previous ones. Was hoping to see Harman grace the stage again (I am a decent dancer only because of him and his NSDLAB dancing secret) Looking forward to seeing a 16 man set with a Ban3r gimmick - if execution is maintained, it'll be murder.

VCU Bhangra: You guys definitely surprised me with the level of cleanliness, but that was honestly it. The formations/choreography were not as creative as we are use to seeing them for VCU Bhangra but that's understandable given the context of recently competing at folk competitions DDA and VPD. However, the biggest thing that detracted was the basketball gimmick at the end. It seemed like an after-thought and was completely unnecessary.

Anakh Punjab Di: Early last week, I was telling my little brother about a old Jay Sean song I use to love called "Me Against Myself" because Jay Sean was honest with himself, knew his faults/short-comings/biggest critiques and turned it around and publicized a self-depreciating song. I loved how you guys did the same with theme and rose above it. However, the execution was unfortunately too weak and my favorite APD performance is still Elite 8 2011. The proposal at the end is something we've always joked about, but it takes real balls to do something like that and you guys made history with it.

Nachde Yaar Punjab De: NYPD was the only Canadian team in the line-up and even when a good portion of the circuit copies the Toronto swag, they set themselves up with their own identity that night. This routine was very refreshing to watch despite all the "India Got Talent"/"Youtube Hiphop" gimmicks that we've already seen here on BTF. The flow and integration of stunts is something that needs to be enhanced. It truly did feel that there was a bhangra segment with formations followed by a stunt followed by the former, then latter..etc. The 300 gimmick did not hit at all and was almost anti-climatic. (TDot was better). But your dancers executed and the mix, stage presence and hype were just murder. It's been way too long since NYPD has won a competition and with the quality of your recent performances, it's really unfortunate.

UNC Bhangra Elite: UNC going last is too deadly. Great formations and amazing execution. I seemed to be one the few people who disliked the marching band, but everything else in the set was entertaining and executed near perfectly. Everything else to say about this team has already been said, but honestly, it's crazy to think that UNC was not even in the original line-up and they came back to win the competition. A collegiate co-ed bhangra team (that built itself in a few years on their own) winning Elite 8 is a sign that the circuit is not run by independent/academy male teams with dancers of 4+ years of experience.

My Winner: Joshiley Jawan
This is my balanced winner. You have NYPD with great creativity and you have UNC with great cleanliness. JJ got both of them right in the middle. UNC set still seems a bit derivative at times and some of their gimmicks seem like they tried too hard. NYPD formations weren't always hit and their ending was too anti-climatic. Had JJ gone in the 2nd half of the show, they would have won.

Final Thoughts:
> Teams put in twice as much effort in preparing for Elite 8 than any other competition, even competitions with more prize money, bigger audiences, more difficult lineups and other incentives. Teams come into Elite 8 with something to prove.

> The audience of Elite 8 is more bhangra-teams-savvy than any other audience. The youngins have watched videos of every team countless time. It's a blessing when the last time you competed is a while back or you've never publicized your videos and it's a curse if you have competed in the last 6 months. I truly feel for both VCU and UNC who recently competed. The latter, despite winning, has been using essentially the same set since Burgh last fall and they could have won with complete full confidence from the audience (and myself as well) had it been seen first at Elite.

> There were multiple incidents/fights that occurred at Elite 8. Only 2 of them have been brought up on BTF, but as Swi mentioned earlier, these are individuals from the teams, not the entire teams. It's unfair to attribute the drunk actions of one person to the entire team, when the rest of the team was not even present or actually thinks well of the judges. That is all.
 
Top