• Bhangra discussion is still going strong. Join us in our Facebook group!

    New user registration has been closed (as it was entirely spam). We encourage you to post in our Facebook group, even if it's a followup to an existing thread. BTF will continue to be archived and hosted here - Saleem

Hype vs. Form/Grace in Bhangra

smehta

New Member
Messages
159
Moderator's Note: topic split from "AEG at Alvin Ailey with Masala Bhangra"

Hey guys, this is the first time i've posted in a long time, and what a great thread it is. I don't want to write a paper, but I would like to equate some of this to yoga, and the new sensation, which is "hot yoga" or "bikram yoga". Yoga and its asanas, the physical stretches and poses you see people completing, were originally made so that a person could train his or her body enough, so that they could sit in a cross legged position and meditate for several hours and reach inner peace. Without properly training the body through the asanas, you cannot sit on the ground cross legged for even 5 minutes (try it I dare you). While I think its great that yoga is being spread through the masses as a way to get in shape/shed pounds/burn calories, it's sad that these new promoters don't mention the original purpose or intent of yoga. Yoga can change, but people should know the knowledge/history and its purpose in the back of their heads. I love me a girl in yoga pants (no offense girls), but I dislike me a girl who speaks of yoga as if it is the same as sitting in a sauna.

Metaphor for masala workout? Think about it on your own.
 

smehta

New Member
Messages
159
I couldn't resist. I wanted to make a whole other topic about this, but I might as well bring it up now. My argument against some of the "out of the box" things happening in bhangra:

Take basketball and how it was when it was invented. Now look at basketball, it has evolved yes, but it has also gotten better skill wise. If there were players that completely skipped dribbling practice and went straight to trying to dunk the ball, it would not be pretty. That is what I believe is happening on the bhangra circuit right now. Many of us watch India teams and herald them for their skill/form/style/nakhra. They are the Bob Cousys, Kareem Abdul Jabars, Wilt Chamberlains, and Michael Jordans of the bhangra world... and to be honest, our level of dancing has not surpassed them. We act like we are lebron jameses and kobes, but we aren't, I can see it. You may say I'm being harsh or judgmental, but compare the form/style/grace of the majority of dancers here to india dancers, and you can see we are far behind. Our fundamentals of bhangra are not there, and if they are there, it is not presented the entire dance. I guarantee it. Now I'm not saying don't do creative things. Creative things are fine as long as the fundamentals are there. Hype factors such as formations, gimmicks, and crazy choreo have over-taken the place of cleanliness, power, and form. People argue that we have to do that because that's what the people want.... no, that's what we made the people want.
 

Arjun Barua

Member
Messages
650
smehta said:
Hey guys, this is the first time i've posted in a long time, and what a great thread it is. I don't want to write a paper, but I would like to equate some of this to yoga, and the new sensation, which is "hot yoga" or "bikram yoga". Yoga and its asanas, the physical stretches and poses you see people completing, were originally made so that a person could train his or her body enough, so that they could sit in a cross legged position and meditate for several hours and reach inner peace. Without properly training the body through the asanas, you cannot sit on the ground cross legged for even 5 minutes (try it I dare you). While I think its great that yoga is being spread through the masses as a way to get in shape/shed pounds/burn calories, it's sad that these new promoters don't mention the original purpose or intent of yoga. Yoga can change, but people should know the knowledge/history and its purpose in the back of their heads. I love me a girl in yoga pants (no offense girls), but I dislike me a girl who speaks of yoga as if it is the same as sitting in a sauna.

Metaphor for masala workout? Think about it on your own.
smehta said:
I couldn't resist. I wanted to make a whole other topic about this, but I might as well bring it up now. My argument against some of the "out of the box" things happening in bhangra:

Take basketball and how it was when it was invented. Now look at basketball, it has evolved yes, but it has also gotten better skill wise. If there were players that completely skipped dribbling practice and went straight to trying to dunk the ball, it would not be pretty. That is what I believe is happening on the bhangra circuit right now. Many of us watch India teams and herald them for their skill/form/style/nakhra. They are the Bob Cousys, Kareem Abdul Jabars, Wilt Chamberlains, and Michael Jordans of the bhangra world... and to be honest, our level of dancing has not surpassed them. We act like we are lebron jameses and kobes, but we aren't, I can see it. You may say I'm being harsh or judgmental, but compare the form/style/grace of the majority of dancers here to india dancers, and you can see we are far behind. Our fundamentals of bhangra are not there, and if they are there, it is not presented the entire dance. I guarantee it. Now I'm not saying don't do creative things. Creative things are fine as long as the fundamentals are there. Hype factors such as formations, gimmicks, and crazy choreo have over-taken the place of cleanliness, power, and form. People argue that we have to do that because that's what the people want.... no, that's what we made the people want.
Sheel, you're growing up so fast! I remember when you were a wee little punkass freshman...


Sidenote -- We're going to be a jorhi for the first time this weekend! Can't think of a better way to end my competitive bhangra career!
 

msghoya

New Member
Messages
63
smehta said:
I couldn't resist. I wanted to make a whole other topic about this, but I might as well bring it up now. My argument against some of the "out of the box" things happening in bhangra:

Take basketball and how it was when it was invented. Now look at basketball, it has evolved yes, but it has also gotten better skill wise. If there were players that completely skipped dribbling practice and went straight to trying to dunk the ball, it would not be pretty. That is what I believe is happening on the bhangra circuit right now. Many of us watch India teams and herald them for their skill/form/style/nakhra. They are the Bob Cousys, Kareem Abdul Jabars, Wilt Chamberlains, and Michael Jordans of the bhangra world... and to be honest, our level of dancing has not surpassed them. We act like we are lebron jameses and kobes, but we aren't, I can see it. You may say I'm being harsh or judgmental, but compare the form/style/grace of the majority of dancers here to india dancers, and you can see we are far behind. Our fundamentals of bhangra are not there, and if they are there, it is not presented the entire dance. I guarantee it. Now I'm not saying don't do creative things. Creative things are fine as long as the fundamentals are there. Hype factors such as formations, gimmicks, and crazy choreo have over-taken the place of cleanliness, power, and form. People argue that we have to do that because that's what the people want.... no, that's what we made the people want.
easily the best/most honest thing i've seen posted on this site in a while.... i could not agree more
 

faizan

Just shut up and dance
Messages
1,736
all post partition bhangra misses the intent of punjabi folk dancing, including the bhangra done in india...
 

voxanimus

<('.'<) (>'.')>
Messages
1,685
anyway i don't really think this thread and the sarina jain issue in general deals with the modern-traditional disjunct. there's modern bhangra, traditional bhangra, and then sarina jain stuff. if modern bhangra (a la AEG, for example) is out of the box, then sarina jain made her own box, several galaxies away from the bhangra one.
 

Kaur

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,294
smehta said:
I couldn't resist. I wanted to make a whole other topic about this, but I might as well bring it up now. My argument against some of the "out of the box" things happening in bhangra:

Take basketball and how it was when it was invented. Now look at basketball, it has evolved yes, but it has also gotten better skill wise. If there were players that completely skipped dribbling practice and went straight to trying to dunk the ball, it would not be pretty. That is what I believe is happening on the bhangra circuit right now. Many of us watch India teams and herald them for their skill/form/style/nakhra. They are the Bob Cousys, Kareem Abdul Jabars, Wilt Chamberlains, and Michael Jordans of the bhangra world... and to be honest, our level of dancing has not surpassed them. We act like we are lebron jameses and kobes, but we aren't, I can see it. You may say I'm being harsh or judgmental, but compare the form/style/grace of the majority of dancers here to india dancers, and you can see we are far behind. Our fundamentals of bhangra are not there, and if they are there, it is not presented the entire dance. I guarantee it. Now I'm not saying don't do creative things. Creative things are fine as long as the fundamentals are there. Hype factors such as formations, gimmicks, and crazy choreo have over-taken the place of cleanliness, power, and form. People argue that we have to do that because that's what the people want.... no, that's what we made the people want.
I completely agree with Sheel, especially us teams who came up when how good a dancers technique was actually matterd 2007-2010.
 

siddyp

Tough times never last, but tough people do.
Messages
1,270
Hkiran said:
smehta said:
I couldn't resist. I wanted to make a whole other topic about this, but I might as well bring it up now. My argument against some of the "out of the box" things happening in bhangra:

Take basketball and how it was when it was invented. Now look at basketball, it has evolved yes, but it has also gotten better skill wise. If there were players that completely skipped dribbling practice and went straight to trying to dunk the ball, it would not be pretty. That is what I believe is happening on the bhangra circuit right now. Many of us watch India teams and herald them for their skill/form/style/nakhra. They are the Bob Cousys, Kareem Abdul Jabars, Wilt Chamberlains, and Michael Jordans of the bhangra world... and to be honest, our level of dancing has not surpassed them. We act like we are lebron jameses and kobes, but we aren't, I can see it. You may say I'm being harsh or judgmental, but compare the form/style/grace of the majority of dancers here to india dancers, and you can see we are far behind. Our fundamentals of bhangra are not there, and if they are there, it is not presented the entire dance. I guarantee it. Now I'm not saying don't do creative things. Creative things are fine as long as the fundamentals are there. Hype factors such as formations, gimmicks, and crazy choreo have over-taken the place of cleanliness, power, and form. People argue that we have to do that because that's what the people want.... no, that's what we made the people want.
I completely agree with Sheel, especially us teams who came up when how good a dancers technique was actually matterd 2007-2010.
I disagree. I think that you can learn to dribble/shoot, but you end up shooting or dribbling with your own style. No one dribbles or shoots with the exact same form.

Every team that has won a competition for a while now has had great TEAM form. There have been very few exceptions. If teams can't execute together, they take themselves out of the picture when it comes to placing. Bhangra is supposed to be fun and entertaining. Having out of the box choreography is what takes teams to the top because of their wow factor and separating themselves from the pack. Just being clean and having good form doesn't win the game no more.
 

dheerja

Member
Messages
607
Sheel I agree with what you're essentially saying, that hype factors have taken over bhangra in place of cleanliness, form, and basic execution of the dance. I think teams that win (SGPD, AEG, FAUJ, etc.) have BOTH hype and form, but unfortunately the majority of teams lack form in favor of hype/gimmicks.

I think the trend towards hype is the result of a few factors that honestly mean it's not going anywhere:
1) The Internet. When you're watching a YouTube video of a performance, even if it's GTV, it's impossible to get the full effect of grace, nakhra, and cleanliness like you would in person. I remember watching PCBCA at Elite last year and being completely blown away by their pure execution of the dance, but watching the same video on YouTube, I didn't feel quite as wow-ed. Instead, videos favor gimmicks and formations since those are easily seen in any quality video. These days the online community has a much greater impact on what a team chooses to do, so I don't see this changing at all.
2) The show audience. With so many new competitions popping up on a yearly basis, it's harder and harder to fill up your auditorium. Remember the days when Bruin used to sell out that massive theatre in Long Beach? That'd be impossible to do for any competition these days. The majority of North American audiences respond much better to hype, gimmicks, and formations than they do to grace and cleanliness because the majority of audiences don't know anything about pure bhangra and how it should be executed. So teams feel the need to cater to these audiences to get that huge crowd response, and competitions feel the need to bring teams that will excite their audience and drive ticket sales.
3) Lack of a traditional base in North America. Over the past two decades we've basically moved in the opposite direction. North American bhangra started out as ULTRA modern and collegiate, and only recently has the growth of academies developed a more fundamental understanding of bhangra's roots. This is growing and will only improve, as we've seen teams improve in execution and form tenfold year to year, but the lack of an inherent culture and tradition like they have in India will always set us back when it comes to placing importance on form vs. hype.


Another note - I actually completely disagree with your basketball analogy. I don't think the two are related at all. Basketball isn't an art form, it's a game focused on winning, achieved by placing a ball in the basket. The game has evolved as general athleticism has evolved, guys can play for an extra decade thanks to new conditioning treatments, etc. The rules of the game have also evolved with the players, catering to Lebron's style of play. However there really is no "right" way to play basketball. We might think that MJ, Wilt, Kareem, etc. played it the way it's supposed to be played, and they're the "pure" basketball players, but that's all pure opinion. At the end of the day, if you're putting points on the board and winning, that's all that matters. Bhangra on the other hand, is purely about execution and how you perform the dance.
 

faysal

New Member
Messages
889
I don't think it has enough to do with the current topic to continue it on here maybe split the topic? but still I think the point Sheel is trying to make is valid, especially for newer teams coming into the circuit they put doing some crazy gimmick or idea first over getting their dancers to execute properly and cleanly and using that to impress the judges. Regardless of what kind of team you have, modern/live/traditional this stuff is still relevant.

Ask yourselves this, why do people still go nutty for a slow down during a live set or even a music set? if 8 guys/girls with proper form get low with strait backs and are bouncing their shoulders in time with their hands in perfect position it is given more applause than a double backflip hand spin chaffa any day. There is no wrong in moving the dance forward whilst still upholding the standard set by the best dancers around. Why should live teams be the only ones that have to execute properly and not get let off for being lazy at the back? it's easy to come up with some crazy shit, it's not so easy to be a crazy good dancer because it's a long ass process that many people aren't willing to go through or maybe just don't have the time to do.
 

dheerja

Member
Messages
607
faysal said:
I don't think it has enough to do with the current topic to continue it on here maybe split the topic? but still I think the point Sheel is trying to make is valid, especially for newer teams coming into the circuit they put doing some crazy gimmick or idea first over getting their dancers to execute properly and cleanly and using that to impress the judges. Regardless of what kind of team you have, modern/live/traditional this stuff is still relevant.

Ask yourselves this, why do people still go nutty for a slow down during a live set or even a music set? if 8 guys/girls with proper form get low with strait backs and are bouncing their shoulders in time with their hands in perfect position it is given more applause than a double backflip hand spin chaffa any day. There is no wrong in moving the dance forward whilst still upholding the standard set by the best dancers around. Why should live teams be the only ones that have to execute properly and not get let off for being lazy at the back? it's easy to come up with some crazy shit, it's not so easy to be a crazy good dancer because it's a long ass process that many people aren't willing to go through or maybe just don't have the time to do.

I don't think anyone's arguing that we should devalue form, but problem is that it is happening. Why and what can be done to change that?
 

faysal

New Member
Messages
889
Why? because teams and dancers are like sheep...they follow the last crazy thing that just happened. Look at all routines post e8 2010 and tell me you don't see a common thread throughout? aside from certain teams like empire or apd A LOT OF teams suddenly decided they were going to stop trying to look like vcu and start trying to emulate that crazy shit they saw nj and sgpd etc try to pull off. Also, I think a lot of it has to do with judging, teams that are sloppy yet more creative have been placing over cleaner simpler teams for a while now and that of course is going to impact the mind set of a team putting a routine together. If you know that just being good dancers and having a clean set isn't enough what else are you going to do but try and think of some crazy formations/choreo to get you those extra points to catch up with those teams that pioneered that style.

As for what can be done to change it, I think you guys may just be too far gone stateside to change any time soon but it will come full circle at some point however I don't see that happening in less than 3/4 years. Until 8/12/16 absolutely ridiculous dancers back to front that dance as a team appear which is more than possible in this next generation of dancers there will not be a change just more development in this current trend.
 

dheerja

Member
Messages
607
I think bhangra dancers are evolving more and more in grace/form, especially now that academies and mentors are more prevalent. I don't see the hype going away for the reasons I stated above - but I do see more teams becoming able to execute a hype routine WITH proper form.

I also don't see this as a HUGE issue. Bhangra trends last MAX 2-3 years, the circuit will change what it does within the next 2 years I bet. It's already oversaturated with gimmicks, which is what we're seeing last year and this year, and at some point it'll switch direction.
 

faysal

New Member
Messages
889
I think complex routines with better form will become the norm with younger teams that have been taught at academies etc or got into the scene at a young age so they come in with an advantage over prior generations. I hope you're right to be honest, because it seems like even those teams that pioneered this current age/style are running out of ideas somewhat. You never know, maybe this e8 will be the turning point for a new trend although I'd imagine it to be a little soon for that to happen.
 

faizan

Just shut up and dance
Messages
1,736
Simple Questions:


1. When was the standard for form set?
2. Where did it come from?
3. Can it evolve?
4. Who says what the standard is?


I always find conversations like this silly, because they are based on aesthetic preferences, not actual historical precedence.
 

Ashveer

New Member
Messages
492
faizan said:
Simple Questions:


1. When was the standard for form set?
2. Where did it come from?
3. Can it evolve?
4. Who says what the standard is?


I always find conversations like this silly, because they are based on aesthetic preferences, not actual historical precedence.
One way to approach this is that whereas the circuit can trace its own lineage, development, and evolution to a certain degree of consensus, Masala Bhangra sort of drops from the sky and masalas it up not to promote or spread culture, but to make a paycheck. There isn't anything inherently wrong with the commodification, SGPD/Empire/academies/BasementBhangra do it all the time. But I think its the lack of due diligence as far as I can tell on Jain's part to research what she is talking about (knowing names of moves, for example) until very recently is disconcerting. On the other hand, she has spent a lot of time with her sister structuring the fitness part of it, marketing it, promoting it, and institutionalizing a training apparatus for it.

And of course, we want to see bhangra made in our own image, and people around the world have been doing that since Youtube came along and a little while later Empire's Bruin 08 video directs people to the circuit and 'our' way of doing bhangra. In the same way that post-partition the 'people' shaped bhanrga, its happening here in NA and we're shaping it for the world, for all the 2007 diasporic dreams of looking exactly like PAU.
 

SanghaSoldier

Member
Messages
218
faysal said:
Also, I think a lot of it has to do with judging, teams that are sloppy yet more creative have been placing over cleaner simpler teams for a while now and that of course is going to impact the mind set of a team putting a routine together.

Tu smart ah. I give you karma :)
 

faysal

New Member
Messages
889
1. You guys set your own high standards every year that passes and they change season to season which is why the scene is the way it is now - crazy ish over cleanliness for the most part. When you review a team you don't tell them hey it's ok you do bethka like you're taking a dump because there is no rule book on bhangra right? music or live there are basic things all coaches teach their dancers.

2. Obviously the inspiration for this "standard" is taken from Punjab teams that are considered the best with "ultimate bhangra" and like Ashveer said PAU etc but no one is saying just go do live but to music, it's about taking the things that are good out of that and applying it to what you're doing.

3. Of couse, Punjab teams did the same thing, the teams in the 2000's simply took the things they considered best out of what the previous generation did and tweaked them and that still goes on now it's just not as dramatic a change as you see in the rest of the world but it's still evolving.

4. The judges, and the coaches, and those pioneer teams that do something different. But look at those teams that go around winning they all tend to have something in common and this applies more to the "traditional" music teams and live teams. They have the "best" dancers at the time in comparison to who? The very Punjab teams they originally took inspiration from. If you don't hold teams and dancers to a basic standard of dancing ability irrespective of creativity then what would be the point of having judges? just have the audience hold cards with scores on lol or base the results on who has the loudest crowd response.

Creativity shouldn't come at the cost of skill.
 

Sher

Member
Messages
91
siddyp said:
Hkiran said:
smehta said:
I couldn't resist. I wanted to make a whole other topic about this, but I might as well bring it up now. My argument against some of the "out of the box" things happening in bhangra:

Take basketball and how it was when it was invented. Now look at basketball, it has evolved yes, but it has also gotten better skill wise. If there were players that completely skipped dribbling practice and went straight to trying to dunk the ball, it would not be pretty. That is what I believe is happening on the bhangra circuit right now. Many of us watch India teams and herald them for their skill/form/style/nakhra. They are the Bob Cousys, Kareem Abdul Jabars, Wilt Chamberlains, and Michael Jordans of the bhangra world... and to be honest, our level of dancing has not surpassed them. We act like we are lebron jameses and kobes, but we aren't, I can see it. You may say I'm being harsh or judgmental, but compare the form/style/grace of the majority of dancers here to india dancers, and you can see we are far behind. Our fundamentals of bhangra are not there, and if they are there, it is not presented the entire dance. I guarantee it. Now I'm not saying don't do creative things. Creative things are fine as long as the fundamentals are there. Hype factors such as formations, gimmicks, and crazy choreo have over-taken the place of cleanliness, power, and form. People argue that we have to do that because that's what the people want.... no, that's what we made the people want.
I completely agree with Sheel, especially us teams who came up when how good a dancers technique was actually matterd 2007-2010.
I disagree. I think that you can learn to dribble/shoot, but you end up shooting or dribbling with your own style. No one dribbles or shoots with the exact same form.
There's a reason you don't see many And1 players in the NBA.
 
Top