• Bhangra discussion is still going strong. Join us in our Facebook group!

    New user registration has been closed (as it was entirely spam). We encourage you to post in our Facebook group, even if it's a followup to an existing thread. BTF will continue to be archived and hosted here - Saleem

Judging at B.C's best

Bhangra Idols

New Member
Messages
215
2nyce said:
Bhangra Idols said:
kundia moocha said:


1. If you were sitting close to the top of the audience, then where were the judges sitting?
2. Did you see every reaction of every judge for each performance?
3. If you were sitting in the audience, how did you get access to backstage?
4. You mentioned "they all had scoring binders and
honestly it was very inconsistent", so you looked at all of the categories in all of the team binders to make comparisons to base an opinion on inconsistencies, while having unauthorized access backstage?

1. They were sitting up in the balcony area where you could see their faces and who they were. Half were sitting on one side and the other half on the other side.
2. I obviously did not see every reaction to the judges because i went to watch the competition and not the judges however being that close to them it's hard to resist the temptation to look over my shoulder every once in a while.
3. to get backstage i got off my seat walked down the theater and ended up backstage
4. I looked at as many scoring binders as possible and since each judge was assigned a category its very easy to remember who was assigned what category and then all i did was go to the teams and just look at those categories that i mentioned earlier.
You know who we all are, but who are you...real name?

Bhangra Idols Admin.
as a committee...you shouldnt worry about ONE person this much that you're consistently replying on a thread. shouldnt you have more stuff to be worried about? competitions? any other business? BTF and one persons opinion on how placings ended up and judging was condoned should NOT matter.

does obama give a fuck if i flush my toilet? no. should Bhangra Idols Admin give a fuck if someone disagrees with the placings? no.
Everyone's entitled to their own opinions, and us a committee will take everyone's opinions into perspective. No one will be neglected, ignored, or passed. So if this one person is distraught about any events at our competition, we will try to stabilize the issue right away, hence consistent replying.

Bhangra Idols Admin.

PS. If anyone would like to contact us direct, please email: info@bhangraidols.com
 

RJOHAL

New Member
Messages
77
kpanesar said:
to be honest with mr. moocha. the bhangra idols comitee is one of the finest ! no questions asked. our team placed 4rth and we have no complaints about the judging. and i really think you should get your facts straight because i also asked some teams and compared binders with other teams and what i saw was that it was very fair and all questions we had about the placing were answered on the spot. people are obv going to alittle angry with the judging because who likes to lose? but after alittle while if u talked to the teams they were very happy with the results and cannot wait for the next show.
+1
This is basically what I was trying to say.

ps. Mr. moocha, you just helped emphasize my point...there is no way you could have gone through so many binders even half, since there were 12 teams!
 

Vijay

Member
Messages
646
+1 2nyce

-1 idols committee. being a "stand up individual" as u call it will just allow you and others to pinpoint kundia moocha to a specific group/org/team. u really shouldnt take 1 person's opinion thattt seriously when u clearly threw one hell of a competition.
 

faizan

Just shut up and dance
Messages
1,736
Throroughly impressed by idols, that judging sounds full proof! Best judging set up i have heard of...and i commend u for calling out the troll who is clearly just a bitter team member or their buddy.
 

KammyT

New Member
Messages
242
kpanesar said:
to be honest with mr. moocha. the bhangra idols comitee is one of the finest ! no questions asked. our team placed 4rth and we have no complaints about the judging. and i really think you should get your facts straight because i also asked some teams and compared binders with other teams and what i saw was that it was very fair and all questions we had about the placing were answered on the spot. people are obv going to alittle angry with the judging because who likes to lose? but after alittle while if u talked to the teams they were very happy with the results and cannot wait for the next show.
agreed.

This was my third time competing at an Idols competition and there has yet to been any complaints..The Idols organizers go out of their ways to respond to any complaints or concerns about the organization, that is why they do great things like giving out the score sheets right after the show and letting the teams ask the judges about any questions they have prior to the competition. There was no other team that got to look at our binder so I have no clue where Mr. Moocha is coming from with that statement. Idols has always been willing to consider anyone's opinion about the competition or results. People need to settle down and take their concerns to the Idols commitee privately or through a PM because starting threads like these aren't going to take you anywhere.

And for those criticising the Idols committee for responding to the complaints of Moocha I don't get where your coming from...Moocha decided to start a public thread stating his complaints about the competition it is only right that the Idols committe responds to the concerns through the public thread. If you don't want the committee to respond to you publicly it is not hard to send them a private message.
 

Nilum

Member
Messages
37
(Why aren't the other placing teams replying? We don't need to hide anything... here you are).

Our team (Duniya Allstars) placed 5th out of the top 7. We were very happy and proud of what we accomplished in the past 3 months, as we just started a new focus with our all girls team (having been coed for many years). We are also very proud of all of the teams who placed higher than us and we cheered louder than them while they were placing. Our Duniya Spirit Squad also cheered for each and every team during the placings! We have been in the game for a long time and know the amount of dedication and hard work that it takes to win a competition. BUT it also takes a certain level of maturity that many people lack.

In the past, we have won Bhangra Idols and placed 2nd at Bhangra Idols and have always been happy with our placing (first, second or none). I noticed in 2005 when we won, people said we should not have won. In 2006 when we placed 2nd, people argued that. We later, went on to win such prestigious competitions such as Bhangra Fusion, Boston Bhangra, South Beach Miami, VIBC etc. (Each time, somebody would post "Why did Duniya win?" The reason our team never posts on forums such as this is b/c myself and the other coaches at Duniya, notice the same thing after each and every competition: Someone, usually a member of a competing team who did not place OR place as high as they should decides to make a new account and complaing about the judging. Please, don't take the victory and glory away from placing teams with negativity. With such a huge judging panel following such regimented score sheets, there is not much room for mistakes.

Every team works hard at every competition and when they win or place, don't take this away from them. We are given a 65 page registration package, perhaps you did not follow it properly. NOBODY except our team looked at our binder that night or after the fact, so I am not sure whose binders were compared, maybe share on here so we are all clear?

I ask teams to do something positive with their judging binder and numerous dvds that were immediately available to us. That is why Raj provides them! There is always room for improvement. Here is a suggestion: Tomorrow night I am holding a meeting with my team to look through our binder and read through all our positive comments and constructive suggestions from the judges. For example: We got a very high mark on Creativity... and anyone who would like to argue our teams creativity at BCs Best, I invite you to do so with me personally. We also got very high marks for formations etc. We lost points on stunts, which I too, think we need to work on as a team. And one of the judges gave us positive comments on all the traditional moves we hit but also named one move that we can work on... and you better believe that is what we will be working on at our next practice!

This is a legit competition. Don't take this away from Raj and the organization committee of BCs Best and Idols. They all work hard to give us the worlds hardest judged competition. If you don't like it, don't apply/don't attend. Don't take it away from the rest of us! Why can't people just say "good job" and leave it be. Try harder next time. I had many Duniya students in the crowd who can not wait until they are 16 so they can compete at Idols also. I want to see this competition last for many years, don't ruin it for my students. We also won the spirit squad Sunday night, does anyone want to argue with that? :) And... the reason we have so much spirit is b/c our fans know how passionate we are about dancing that they love watching us no matter what the results are.

There are tons of competitions! Keep up the good work to all of the teams! AND to the placing teams, congratulations, don't let bitter people take your victory away from you. To the audience who appreciated this amazing show for what it was, thank you for all your support to all the teams. To BCs Best committee, thank you for all your hard work, SOME of us appreciate it.

To the rest of you... nobody is an expert here. My hip hop coach once told me "Dancers are always learning." There is a lot of room for improvement. I have been doing competitive Bhangra for over 10 years and I learn something every practice. Rather than using competition results as an excuse to complain, use them as an excuse to grow.

Duniya Allstars Bhangra
Duniya Dance Academy Inc.
 

AmyDee

New Member
Messages
215
Vijay said:
+1 2nyce

-1 idols committee. being a "stand up individual" as u call it will just allow you and others to pinpoint kundia moocha to a specific group/org/team. u really shouldnt take 1 person's opinion thattt seriously when u clearly threw one hell of a competition.
Kundian Moochan should be pinpointed to a group ,organization or team because that is exactly what he is doing to Bhangra Idols as an organization.Being the epitome of a fairly judged and organized competition Bhangra Idols would obviously be hurt by this thread made my Kundian Moochan.This organization always throws awesome competitions and is VERY well known by the bhangra community. You would expect them not to care about just 1 persons opinion or even take it that seriously since they are very well established but their heads are not that far up their asses. They care.

Kundian if you were THAT concerned with the judging of the competition you would have contacted Paji Guys DIRECTLY and PROFESSIONALLY and dealt with this matter. CLEARLY you want to ruin the image of the competition and that is more important to you than fair judging. ANYONE who knows Paji Guys is aware that they are all VERY approachable. If you wanted to protect your identity why not send a PRIVATE ,anonymous email? Your a troll.
 

Nilum

Member
Messages
37
To Amy Dee:

"Exactly"

Should be fairly easy to discover the "troll." Which teams showed anyone other than team members their judging binder? We certainly didn't.
 

HermanJ.

New Member
Messages
125
If people really have a problem, it would better to say it straight up without making a fake account. Doesn't really give you credibility at all.
 

Kaur

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,294
Herman said:
If people really have a problem, it would better to say it straight up without making a fake account. Doesn't really give you credibility at all.
+1
 

Sharin

New Member
Messages
51
"does obama give a fuck if i flush my toilet? no. should Bhangra Idols Admin give a fuck if someone disagrees with the placings? no."

hahaha
 

JaneN

New Member
Messages
11
"We are what we repeatedly do. Excellence, therefore, is not an act but a habit"

Bhangra Idols has proven excellence in 2005, 2006, 2008, 2009, 2010, and now 2011 in the categories of judging panel, registration package (its 65 pages!), organization, professionalism, credibility, and integrity (ie: BC Human Rights)...among others. Furthermore, as each competition passed, they have asked teams how to improve their competition and have implemented these suggestions to achieve the best show possible year after year. As a member of a team that has placed and not placed over the last six years (at this exact competition), I can say with confidence that we have never questioned the placings and completely trust the Bhangra Idols administration and judging panel to award the deserving teams.

Congrats to everyone involved with Bhangra Idols on a successful show for the SIXTH year in a row :)

 

AmyDee

New Member
Messages
215
JaneN said:
"We are what we repeatedly do. Excellence, therefore, is not an act but a habit"

Bhangra Idols has proven excellence in 2005, 2006, 2008, 2009, 2010, and now 2011 in the categories of judging panel, registration package (its 65 pages!), organization, professionalism, credibility, and integrity (ie: BC Human Rights)...among others. Furthermore, as each competition passed, they have asked teams how to improve their competition and have implemented these suggestions to achieve the best show possible year after year. As a member of a team that has placed and not placed over the last six years (at this exact competition), I can say with confidence that we have never questioned the placings and completely trust the Bhangra Idols administration and judging panel to award the deserving teams.

Congrats to everyone involved with Bhangra Idols on a successful show for the SIXTH year in a row :)

+1
 
Top