J Wong
Member
- Messages
- 301
So I was looking at various competition rubrics and I have noticed a lot of things that, in my opinion, shouldn't be there:
1. Points for segments (The point of a rubric is to determine who the best team is of the night, I don't agree that XYZ team should automatically get points because they had jhummar.)
2. Points for vardiyaan (I think it is generally expected that teams come in vardiyaan and not sweatpants.
3. Points for dholi/singer (While I personally like both, this puts teams without access at an inherent disadvantage.
Additionally, there is always the question of modern vs. traditional vs. live, and how to judge them equally. The only way to achieve this is to judge them on the merits of technical ability. Essentially stripping the rubric of all things that may be inherently biased. So I drafted a sample rubric that I believe does just that, the categories only pertain to the basic elements of judging competitive dance.
See link:
http://cl.ly/image/2Q0x460N443a
1. Points for segments (The point of a rubric is to determine who the best team is of the night, I don't agree that XYZ team should automatically get points because they had jhummar.)
2. Points for vardiyaan (I think it is generally expected that teams come in vardiyaan and not sweatpants.
3. Points for dholi/singer (While I personally like both, this puts teams without access at an inherent disadvantage.
Additionally, there is always the question of modern vs. traditional vs. live, and how to judge them equally. The only way to achieve this is to judge them on the merits of technical ability. Essentially stripping the rubric of all things that may be inherently biased. So I drafted a sample rubric that I believe does just that, the categories only pertain to the basic elements of judging competitive dance.
See link:
http://cl.ly/image/2Q0x460N443a