• Bhangra discussion is still going strong. Join us in our Facebook group!

    New user registration has been closed (as it was entirely spam). We encourage you to post in our Facebook group, even if it's a followup to an existing thread. BTF will continue to be archived and hosted here - Saleem

Past team members on judging panel

Is it reasonable to have past member(s) on judging panel for a comp where the former teams are compe

  • Yes

    Votes: 12 33.3%
  • No

    Votes: 24 66.7%

  • Total voters
    36

nine16jatt

New Member
Messages
100
Please vote.. Keep in mind the judge is affiliated with both of the competing teams and still has relation also the team members are still the same
 

Saleem

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
1,928
I think it's silly to pose this question without context. How long ago were they on the team? Do they have any continued relationship to the team?

If I recall, I first judged Cornell 3 years after I left. In that time, almost the entire team turned over, and I hadn't been involved in any of their dances after graduating. I had judged prior to that and felt confident I could be objective. **shrug** up to your opinion after that.
 

nine16jatt

New Member
Messages
100
yes sorry there wasnt enough detail to the thread and was misguiding but the vote count was in 11 to 6 in that respected order those will be added to these
 

Saleem

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
1,928
Can we just get the judge and competition info and discuss the situation itself? No need for a poll on semi-hypotheticals
 

sangeensingh

Member
Messages
717
One word: credibility.

I know of judges that have judged their own previous team(s) just as hard as they judge any other team, and ive also heard of judges "picking favorites" so to speak.

But yeah, Saleem is right, it really depends.

On another note though, I do feel that even if many years have passed since a judge has been affiliated with a team, deep down inside a slight bias will still remain. Its only human.
 
Top