• Bhangra discussion is still going strong. Join us in our Facebook group!

    New user registration has been closed (as it was entirely spam). We encourage you to post in our Facebook group, even if it's a followup to an existing thread. BTF will continue to be archived and hosted here - Saleem

Should a team be penalized for slips/falls?

Pankaja

Member
Messages
7
Just curious what other people think about this. Should a team be docked points because 1 person slips and/or falls? Of course there are situations where people are slipping all over the place because of reason X, Y, Z which can be listed as distracting from the overall performance. There's also the case of someone's chaadar or something falling which can be a wardrobe malfunction which can be a point deduction.

But should a team who has a person slip or fall be penalized at all? One of the best examples I can think of is NJ at E8 when the guy in the front face planted:

http://youtu.be/CQONiA3174Y?t=7m35s

There was also the case at Bayside last spring in which the girl from MBT either slipped or tripped and went down:

http://youtu.be/ZvwwHYNz6hg?t=4m45s

But in both of these cases, the person got right back up and kept dancing. For that reason, I as a judge wouldn't penalize the team for a slip. Of course, these are two of the most extreme examples of people falling on stage and most slips go far less noticed. But what sucks, I think, is that judges indeed dock points from teams if a person or people were slipping. Just curious to see what other people thought about this, whether you agree with me or your reasoning for disagreeing.
 

faizan

Just shut up and dance
Messages
1,736
Slips/falls=penalty


If it takes away from cleanliness, it's got to be docked.
 

siddyp

Tough times never last, but tough people do.
Messages
1,270
faizan said:
Slips/falls=penalty


If it takes away from cleanliness, it's got to be docked.
yes. building on that, how significant was the slip/fall? If the dancer recovers fine, then it should be just a point. If they don't and it effects their dancing, it'll end up becoming more as the performance continues.
 

faizan

Just shut up and dance
Messages
1,736
But for the most part, slips aren't any fault of the team. The stage might be slippery or something else that is out of the control of the team. It doesn't seem right for a team to not do as well at a competition because of something that happens to them as opposed to something that they do

How can you determine, as a judge, on the spot, if a slip is the team's fault, or the stage's fault? Due to this reason, I err on the side of penalty. Even if the floor is slippery, a team should take a quick sweep of the stage before it performs.


When I used to dance, I made sure there was nothing on the floor that could cause any kind of mishaps, BEFORE we performed. Broken pieces of vardiyan, debris from gimmicks, wet spots, I definitely made it a point to look out for things like that before my team went on. It's on teams to keep stages safe, cuz no one else is gonna do it.
 

HarmanToor

Nachde Yaar Punjab De
Messages
487
Perfection is the name of the game, so yea it should be penalized. But to be fair, I think half the points the team lost should be awarded back if the dancers recovery was exceptional. Also, the team is responsible for making sure the stage is clean and clear of any surface imperfections that might lead to a fall or injury.
 

walkertexasjr

Member
Messages
48
I think the majority of slips, etc. aren't noticeable until you go back and watch the video, in which case they won't be penalized. If a slip/fall is noticeable in real time to the audience/judges then simply because of that fact yes it should be docked b/c it takes away from the cleanliness of the routine and the overall impression of the dance at the time. I can remember Cornell at Blowout '10 had a really solid entertaining set but two people slipped/fell in that routine very noticeably, and at the time I felt like they didn't place as a result. In a tight competition those things are (and should be) important. The stage isn't slippery for only one team, every team has to deal with that, etc.


Additionally, I feel like a lot of slips/falls are due to wardrobe issues (girls' pant legs, guys' chadres) or execution/form issues (unbalanced going down, misplaced feet for a spin, etc.) and very rarely anyone or anything but the dancers'/teams' fault.
 

Sue Sylvester

kinnell
Messages
467
A judge evaluates the end product. Slips & falls hurt the cleanliness of the end product, so hell yeah, they should be penalized within the specified category of coordination/cleanliness/synchronization. I don't believe X amount of "points" should be deducted for each transgression and Y amount of "points" returned for the grace of recovery. I think it should be factored into the coordination score and the penalty relative to the degree of "distraction" from team synchronization.


Flawlessly coordinated team with a single slip that was barely noticeable? I could still see the argument for full marks in cleanliness. Flawlessly coordinated team with a major slip but with Peter Griffin injury recovery that lasts the rest of the routine? Yeah, take off a few points.
 

yraparla

SwizzeeMusic.com
Messages
2,072
Sue Sylvester said:
A judge evaluates the end product. Slips & falls hurt the cleanliness of the end product, so hell yeah, they should be penalized within the specified category of coordination/cleanliness/synchronization. I don't believe X amount of "points" should be deducted for each transgression and Y amount of "points" returned for the grace of recovery. I think it should be factored into the coordination score and the penalty relative to the degree of "distraction" from team synchronization.


Flawlessly coordinated team with a single slip that was barely noticeable? I could still see the argument for full marks in cleanliness. Flawlessly coordinated team with a major slip but with Peter Griffin injury recovery that lasts the rest of the routine? Yeah, take off a few points.
Exactly, I think the key difference is 'penalizing' versus 'evaluating'. I think it absolutely should be part of the evaluation under appropriate category. But it gets hard when penalizing points because the value of a point is pretty ethereal. Is 2 min of solid clean dancing worth a point? Are 2 slips equivalent to a point? Remember that one time Shah Rukh slipped on a baitka but recovered and barely skipped a beat, does that warrant a point penalty? It's arbitrary and an unnecessary burden on judges.

If you simply evaluate mistakes within the framework of the established categories you'll invariably score the team lower (and if you don't, then clearly the mishaps didn't affect the performance enough, so there's no reason for point loss).
 

Ajay.H

New Member
Messages
142
Pankaja said:
Okay, fair enough. Given that we have established point deductions for slips and whatever deviations from cleanliness. How can a team try to prevent this, if at all?

It was mentioned earlier that you should look around on the stage to see if there is anything but is that really feasible? The stage is usually pretty dark while setting up and the intro vid is playing so I'm not really sure what can be done to prevent it
If it's not something visible (and therefore easily taken care of) that the previous team left on stage (prop, vardi accessory, remnant gimmick), then its probably something that every team is dealing with (slippery floor). I guess talk with your teams before competitions about how to handle that kind of situation, if the stage is slippery and just to be more careful to your own judgment.

You can also harp on your competition organizer/side stage crew to either sweep between performances or at least help you sweep before your performance. Sometimes its things you can notice during tech and try to get taken care of. It does suck though - At a mixed comp, I had a little bell from a raas team's dandia stuck in my foot for about the entire performance.
 

faizan

Just shut up and dance
Messages
1,736
Spray feet with copious amounts of hairspray before you perform...it will battle a slippery stage for at least half the performance...and for the other half, Godspeed.
 

Kaur

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,294
All teams dance on the same stage, it's unfortunate if other teams don't slip and you do. Some rubrics have (-5) deduction for wardrobe malfunction. So If it's your chadra or your salwar comes unpinned its an automatic deduction. If you fall and it's a wardrobe malfunction then I personally don't think separate points should be taken off for the slip. Rubrics which don't have a deduction for wardrobes and you just slip and fall then it's up to the discretion of the judge to deduct/ give recovery points.

It's kind of like being sick before you go on stage. It's not written on a dancers forehead that 'please go easy on me I am sick." A judge doesn't know the circumstances behind a bad performance and sometimes they don't see why you fell.

Flawless and clean is the name of the game.
 

jasraj93

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,122
personally it depends on the fall and recovery, if there was suppose to be a gimmick which failed i would deduct points because it was a risk the team was willing to take, if it was just a slip but the dancer recovered very fast and kept going with consistent energy then i wouldn't.
 

voxanimus

<('.'<) (>'.')>
Messages
1,685
Pankaja said:
faizan said:
Spray feet with copious amounts of hairspray before you perform...it will battle a slippery stage for at least half the performance...and for the other half, Godspeed.
hahaha wouldn't that just create a hardened shell on your feet that's even more slippery than before?

no, that's if you let it harden. if you "stick" it to stuff before it gets a chance, it'll make a gummy residue on the bottom of your feet that's really sticky.


2 problems with this though


1) if you're not used to dancing like this, you'll look like this dog:


Dogs' new shoes


2) an unholy amount of grime will collect on your feet.
 

faizan

Just shut up and dance
Messages
1,736
Hairspray creates traction, not stickiness (try it and you'll see)


Although, the mess on your feet is def. gonna happen...
 

Multani

Member
Messages
551
Don't be slipping on stage homeboy, keep those feet on the ground. Every team should take extra couple or so minutes to clear the stage before performance if organizers allow the time.
 

mafzal

Judge / Dancer
Messages
2,098
I would deduct, yes... although maybe just 1 point. An amazing team with some slips could still win first, but if two teams are neck and neck, then the one with less mistakes (however unfortunate or accidental they may be) should win...

As someone mentioned even an accidental fall that is not your fault at all, it's still a detraction from the performance and we can't have everyone going up to judges after each performance explaining what happen... it is what it is. Same as when you're sick, you can't make an announcement at the beginning of the performance saying, "hey everyone, I got the flu last night, etc etc"... c'est la vie

Definitely agree on HK mentioning not double-counting wardrobe malfunctions. If a girl's salwar is too long and the pin comes undone and it opens up, that's a point deduction. If she slips on it and falls, clearly because of the wardrobe malfunction, I would not take off additional points.
 

J-Skeet

New Member
Messages
252
Really does suck when this happens on stage, but to be quite frank points should be deducted. However, the degree of impact the fall/slip had on the performance, the fall itself, and the recovery should each hold value. Some people are saying that if a dancer falls and they have an exceptional recover then that team would get some point back. Well what if the recovery was piss-poor? Definitely have more points reduced on top of the fall. Now obviously all of this is subjective, but at the end of the day one thing is for certain--->No how good the recovery, or how non-noticeable the fall was, the fall must dictate some time of deduction on the score sheet.
 
Top