Pankaja
Member
- Messages
- 7
Just curious what other people think about this. Should a team be docked points because 1 person slips and/or falls? Of course there are situations where people are slipping all over the place because of reason X, Y, Z which can be listed as distracting from the overall performance. There's also the case of someone's chaadar or something falling which can be a wardrobe malfunction which can be a point deduction.
But should a team who has a person slip or fall be penalized at all? One of the best examples I can think of is NJ at E8 when the guy in the front face planted:
http://youtu.be/CQONiA3174Y?t=7m35s
There was also the case at Bayside last spring in which the girl from MBT either slipped or tripped and went down:
http://youtu.be/ZvwwHYNz6hg?t=4m45s
But in both of these cases, the person got right back up and kept dancing. For that reason, I as a judge wouldn't penalize the team for a slip. Of course, these are two of the most extreme examples of people falling on stage and most slips go far less noticed. But what sucks, I think, is that judges indeed dock points from teams if a person or people were slipping. Just curious to see what other people thought about this, whether you agree with me or your reasoning for disagreeing.
But should a team who has a person slip or fall be penalized at all? One of the best examples I can think of is NJ at E8 when the guy in the front face planted:
http://youtu.be/CQONiA3174Y?t=7m35s
There was also the case at Bayside last spring in which the girl from MBT either slipped or tripped and went down:
http://youtu.be/ZvwwHYNz6hg?t=4m45s
But in both of these cases, the person got right back up and kept dancing. For that reason, I as a judge wouldn't penalize the team for a slip. Of course, these are two of the most extreme examples of people falling on stage and most slips go far less noticed. But what sucks, I think, is that judges indeed dock points from teams if a person or people were slipping. Just curious to see what other people thought about this, whether you agree with me or your reasoning for disagreeing.