• Bhangra discussion is still going strong. Join us in our Facebook group!

    New user registration has been closed (as it was entirely spam). We encourage you to post in our Facebook group, even if it's a followup to an existing thread. BTF will continue to be archived and hosted here - Saleem

The "future" of bhangra (stage dance)?

siddyp

Tough times never last, but tough people do.
Messages
1,270
Gabbah Shareef Bhalwan said:
Do you think the could do the same but use bhangra (i.e rather than hip hop, raas, etc) and keep it from getting monotonous?
prob not.. it really depends on the crowd. to a normal audience member, all the mixes/music sounds the same. putting something that isn't bhangra in between allows the bhangra to stand out more and each performance becomes more refreshing.
 
Messages
237
OK, thanks. This takes me back to my question of what are the differences between an exhibition team performance and a competition team performance.


At some point in the past (before 2005), I got the sense that the first "exhibition" teams were there to show people "how it's done." They were groups like Surrey India Arts Club and Punjabi Lok Virsa, who people believed did better bhangra because they had more experience and better access to "the tradition." The "regular" teams looked to them as models.


So at the same time, these teams had to be "exhibitional" because it would be unfair to put their "authentic" bhangra against the seemingly inferior stuff that "the kids" were doing. The "exhibition" groups were "too good" to "waste" their time competing anyway. What they were doing was "the art," and competing was an activity to be done by college kids who hadn't developed fully yet.


Correct me if I am remembering this wrong.


Now, from what I am hearing, people consider "exhibitional" as a place for people who "didn't make it" in competition. These groups are considered lacking, inexperienced. They are being "given a chance." Competing teams are considered to be the best, the mark of excellence.


Can you guys see how this is a shift? It means that, whether individuals believe it or not, the reality has become that that bhangra is best which is competitive. And there would be no difference in the "exhibition" teams, because they too are striving for the form of competition bhangra. This leaves little room to do things outside the "square stage, few judges, and screaming audience" format and the guidelines of rubrics.
 

nubucks

New Member
Messages
22
I think we're underestimating how bhangra has become a part of south asian culture in colleges. Kids coming into school immediately look to it, and notice it if they've never heard of it before. The beats are bumping, the dance is athletic, and it's incredibly fun to perform and watch. Maybe I'm biased, I'm not looking at the circuit as a whole, but I don't think it's going anywhere.
 
Top