There are two main factors to any routine - cleanliness and creativity.
You guys are extremely clean and the routine was beautifully executed. To the latter, I give you almost full marks. (Mistakes were still made) You guys are creative and definitely one of the more creative collegiate teams. But compared against what we've seen from independent teams in the past 2 months (Idols, Burgh..etc), you fall short in regards to pushing the envelope. Your creativity is subtle and still refreshing and you are definitely the hottest collegiate team out there now, but this was not "next level" nor did I think it was "hands-down first". Those who thought so should re-evaluate what that really means before jumping that bandwagon. I'm not saying this didn't deserve first because I wasn't at Burgh and I don't know the technicalities of what went down, but I'm failing to see the hype everyone on BTF seems to be pumping into this performance. A lot of your x-factors were variations and recycle of ideas already executed by other teams. I'm not looking down on them, but I'm saying it's nothing new or out-of-the-box.
To re-iterate, extremely clean, one of the best collegiate team performances in recent months, but creativity still falls short when compared to the independent teams.