• Bhangra discussion is still going strong. Join us in our Facebook group!

    New user registration has been closed (as it was entirely spam). We encourage you to post in our Facebook group, even if it's a followup to an existing thread. BTF will continue to be archived and hosted here - Saleem

Universal Bhangra Judging Form

hardeep_singh

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,463
Developed this myself because bhangra competitions still use judging sheets/criteria developed for bollywood/fusion performances.

Instructions for Use:
1. All competing teams provide the following information to the competition/judges prior to competition
- Number of segments
- Type and order of segments in the set
2. Judges grade each performance based on two scores for each segment.
3. Segment: A section of a performance consisting of at least 30 seconds of choreo.
3. Execution Score: How well a segment was executed with respect to energy, cleanliness, and move completion.
4. Difficulty/Creativity Score: Difficulty level of a segment with respect to choreo complexity, choreo speed and modulation of speed, stage usage (movement of dancers). Creativity level of a segment with respect to style, move and sequence complexities, variations and uniqueness of move execution.
5. Comment section should be used to record important details/notes about each segment.
6. Along with the segment scores another score category will be completed once the performance has concluded. This category is the set flow/segment transitions, which provides a score for the overall set flow with respect to how seamless the performance was and how cohesive the set was thematically.
7. The average score will be calculated from the segment and set flow scores.
8. Judges will use the Deductions and Additions sections to during the performance to record point deductions and additions.
9. The final score will be calculated using the average score, total deductions, and total additions.

I've attached pdf files of a blank form and an example form I filled in for a performance a friend wanted feedback for.
 

hardeep_singh

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,463
the previous method of judging posted was definitely much more complicated than necessary. i think it would be difficult for judges to keep up with the performance and simultaneously score everything segment by segment. so i developed a simplified method which i believe allows for proper judging and keeps the math simple.
 

Attachments

arnab

Member
Messages
77
Interesting @hardeep_singh - I don't think I've ever judged or been judged using a segment/time based rubric. There's definitely some value there. If I know the skeleton of what a set is going to look like then I can anticipate what's coming and be better prepared to translate my thoughts into scores. Actually thought the segment based scoring makes more sense than time based, since time assumes that the relative value of 0-2 min is equal to 4-6 min, for example.

I think something to be careful of (and this is not just your rubric) is careful use of the word "and" in sections. For example, energy *and* synchronization are very different performance elements. Creativity *and* difficulty are very different performance elements. They can, and I think should, be in different categories. When rubrics group unrelated elements it makes it very difficult to weigh each in your mind while judging.

I have lots of thoughts about including "traditional moves" in bhangra rubrics, and how bonuses/deductions should work... maybe for another time!
 

hardeep_singh

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,463
the use of "and" was intentional and relevant/justified:
creativity and difficulty: subcategories relevant for the analysis/judging of choreography
segment transitions and set flow: overall cohesiveness of the set
formations and stage usage: dynamic movement of the dancers
energy and synchronicity: factors relevant for the analysis of how the dancers performed the choreo
traditional moves: category to allow for competitions to define required elements
opening and ending: entertainment value of beginning and ending of the set

any time increment section of a performance is inherently equivalent to every other section unless there are any substantial pauses in dancing during the increment being judged.
 

Howie Magz

Well-Known Member
Messages
454
I actually like this rubric it really breaks down every segment and looks real deep into everyone's set design and execution. Really like how it can be applicable to both live and music sets. @hardeep_singh nice stuff man.
 
Top