• Bhangra discussion is still going strong. Join us in our Facebook group!

    New user registration has been closed (as it was entirely spam). We encourage you to post in our Facebook group, even if it's a followup to an existing thread. BTF will continue to be archived and hosted here - Saleem

WBBC Competition Reviews

Gsimz

Ne Asi Gabroo Desh Punjab De ;)
Messages
491
10/10

Akum pretty much summed it up for us FS guys, but next year you should have AEG open or close up the show ;)
 

aneeshsahni

New Member
Messages
60
Has the rubric been posted anywhere? If not, can somebody post it?


Also, this would just be a small change but something to take note of. For DCBC (the first team up), the audience was somewhat empty and a lot of people were filing into the auditorium at that time. I think this is because you guys started around 6:30, which is pretty solid considering the listed time was 6:00. You might just wanna have people be like "first performance starting in X number of minutes!!!!" so that everyone knows not to operate on full indian standard time.


I just didn't realize that the show was actually starting, and it would've been nice to see more of DCBC's set, and as a dancer you want to be in front of a full crowd and it can be distracting to have a lot of people filing in/finding seats/etc.
 

kdshah

Member
Messages
39
GREAT comp, minus a few things-


1. lack practice space friday night/being in 30 degree weather (us southern folks aren't used to that!)


2. the whole afterparty fiasco. didn't even get to the party before it was shut down and the whole noise complaint thing was annoying. not sure if comps have tried this before but why not reserve the bottom 2 floors for teams so no guests are bothered? since this is planned so far in advance, i'm sure the hotels could accomodate.


3. lack of balcony at the venue/upper level judging. if you're gonna have upper and lower level judging with upper having heavy points for creativity of formations, there's got to be a balcony for judges to be able to properly see formations. i'm sure many teams had moments that didn't hit because the audience and judges couldn't see it happen, so the validity of the upper level rubric is kind of lost. lack of balcony also makes teams have to walk in front of cameras/judges/general audience, which i'm sure was annoying. i also think videos from the balcony are so much better.


the mixer, the communication, flexibility, sticking to schedule, and general organization were phenomenal! it really felt like the committee was there to help in however way they could and were willing to do anything they could for the teams. i know next years will be absolutely amazing! congrats to ankush, faizan, jaggi and the whole committee for showing all of us teams such a great time!
 

Reeeeda

Member
Messages
71
Anything I would have liked to have pointed out has already been mentioned, so I will keep this short in attempt to not be too repetitive.

WBBC was a great competition as most anyone (audience member or teams) will agree to.

Mixer
- Love the match-up shirt idea and the way the mixer game was set up. Definitely think this should carry over to next year. However, would've liked a chance to mix with the other teams as well. Maybe an additional game would be a good idea? Just a thought.
- Food was okay... I personally am not big on desi food the night before, but most everyone seemed happy with it
- Mixer venue was a bit small - couldn't walk around comfortably and even for the mixer games, it was a bit crowded.
- All in all, mixer was a good time - everyone had fun - that much was apparent.
- Completely approve of the way lineup was chosen at random. no bullshit is always a good thing.
- Going to repeat what people already have said about the lack of practice space. Looks like the committee is already on top of it for next year, so I wont go further into it

Tech Time/The show
- Bagels for breakfast, subs for lunch, and pizza for dinner
- AMAZING sound system at the venue
- Huge stage
- There was not much waiting around for tech time, which was nice. We were in and out.
- Loved the setup of tech time (2 additional minutes granted on top to setup and move off)

- Superwoman was great. Kept the crowd entertained and everything moved along swiftly.
- Award ceremony is one thing I feel like could have moved a bit faster. Not sure what the holdup was

After party
- Whatever I have to say here would only be echoing what has already been said. Not even complaining about it, because we had a great time hanging out with everyone in our hotel rooms anyway :)

The one thing I do need to raise a flag about is that our team name was misspelled on our trophy, which kinda sucks. That's basically the only thing I can really say I'm not happy about. Other than that, this competition was so much fun. Teams got along, organizers were always around to help. We were well taken care of, always had water and food. I hope other competitions can learn from competitions like WBBC and Elite 8 - the two most well run competitions in my experience.

A few shout outs:
- DCBC: you girls were awesome and great competitors. It was fun getting to know you at the mixer and we hope to share a stage with you lovely ladies again in the near future!

- Kush: thank you for always being available. You were great, always calling and staying in constant communication. Got us whatever we needed and went out of your way to make sure we were all good. We really appreciate everything!

- Sumit and Raj: thank you for helping SMD extensively with our show ticket orders. Always available and so responsive.

- Ankush, Faizan and the rest of WBBC: thank you for living up to what you promised and delivering more than what teams could have expected from a first year comp. You guys have been extremely patient with SMD and with the rest of the teams as well. I applaud you for all your efforts and the success. I don't doubt for a second that next year is going to be even better :)
 

Sue Sylvester

kinnell
Messages
467
After this weekend, it's obvious that WBBC is on it's way on becoming World's Best Bhangra Competition. A lot of new things were tried, but at the end of the day, it still felt like a normal bhangra competition weekend that didn't really have its boundaries pushed or bar raised. However, the organizers proved themselves capable enough to throw a first-year well-run sold-out competition to simply test the waters so I can only expect that next year will have some bloody brilliant shit.

Most of the good comments and critiques have already been written, but here are a few more thoughts.

The lack of a back-up plan for the after-party was unfortunate. I'm just not a fan of hotel banquet halls. Maybe I like the prestige of a club atmosphere, or maybe I know that club bouncers are more likely to accept a wad of $20 bills tucked in my fingers than hotel bouncers. Whatever it is, I think having a back-up plan like an after-after party would have been nice.

I thought the parking lot was a great spacious spot for the late night practicing had the hotel been okay with it. A bit chilly, but convenient in terms of location.

The venue was good this year, but hopefully you guys can snag a bigger and nicer venue next year, especially given the prestige of the competition as "World's Best Bhangra Crew". I know you guys tried to make a live-feed work in the back, but I guess that didn't work out? That would have been one of the major highlights in every post in this thread as every team could have gotten ready and watched almost every team without having to run back and forth from the auditorium.

The organizers and WBBC committee were another highlight of this event. They were very capable and involved with the event. It was refreshing to hear that committee members were not allowed to drink until 3 AM after the competition. Not sure if this was enforced but it certainly shows how seriously the organizers took the competition. Hell, I was coming to the venue when I was asked to show my roster band by a committee member that I happened to know. I got curious and tried to coax my way into the venue without showing my band. (I had did have one, but I can be a bitch sometimes...err often :) ) But despite the fact that I had been jodis with him on AEG back at Elite 8 2010, he still held his ground and asked to see my band because that was his job. Ankush, Faizan and Raj went out of their ways in their own capacity to make sure that the teams were happy.

The competition format is interesting and has ramifications in intriguing and surprising ways. None of these rivalries truly existed before WBBC, but afterwards, they certainly do in some degree or another. When a team gets put in a match-up, the spotlight has essentially been put on them. They're either going to win or they're going to lose. That feeling of motivation to not lose your match-up isn't present at your normal competition because if you don't place at the normal competition, you're one out of 5-9 teams that didn't place - "oh well, afterparty time!". Here, at WBBC, you're 1 out of 2 that didn't win the match-up and as Faizan said, it pushes teams to really go out and it was evident in all of the performances.

However, you also have a drawback. In the scenario of your normal competition, let's say Team A got first, Team B got second and Team C got third. At WBBC, Team A could be matched up with Team B and Team C with Team Papaya. Team A could win their match-up and win overall and Team C could make Team Papaya look like fruits, but Team B would not have any sense of validation for what would have been a 2nd place performance at any other competition. You can chalk it up to this being a "different" competition, but a competition that doesn't reward the top performances in some way or the other is flawed to me. At the very least, it makes teams re-evaluate who they are matched up with or whether this is worth competing at for the bigger teams. If SGPD and NJ went head to head against each other and came out with the best performances ever, one of them would go home without a trophy while other teams at the competition who may not have normally placed could still get bling. But, I'm sure that WBBC will think of a creative way to fix this (ie: Award for best match-up aka match-up with the highest combined scores, ranking the match-ups?).

In regards to judging, I commend the WBBC team in striving to switch it up and improve the rubric. There was some good ideas and the Google Hangouts you had with the other teams and the judges leading up to the event was a great way to improve the process with the teams involved and keep them in the loop. Like Kuntal mentioned, the venue didn't create a real need for the upper-balcony judge as formations were difficult to see regardless, but I guess it allows those judges to focus more specifically than trying to judge every category, which can only be beneficial. My only qualm with the judging is that judges need to evaluate performances with what is presented in front of them relative to the other teams and not bring up or even consider components from the team's previous competitions, especially if they had judged there before. Other than that, the judges were qualified and competent. And Ankush, release the score sheets!

In the end, the major components of a competition experience are mixer, rehearsal, competition, teams and afterparty. It may have been out of your control, but a competition weekend isn't the same without a centralized afterparty. 9/10
 

faizan

Just shut up and dance
Messages
1,736
A 9/10 from sue is 10/10 for me.

sue, real quick, doesn't elite 8 only have one winner with no award for 2 or 3? I think a championship should only go to 1 team, personally.

Most other comps reward 2nd and 3rd, but we wanted every team to strive to be the champion, hence why there was only 1 winner.

Best match-up of the night is for sure a good idea.
 

Sue Sylvester

kinnell
Messages
467
faizan said:
sue, real quick, doesn't elite 8 only have one winner with no award for 2 or 3? I think a championship should only go to 1 team, personally.
I think the difference is that half the line-up that wins their match-up goes home with recognition as oppose to just 1 team winning 1 award. Teams with weaker performances could potentially get a trophy and teams with stronger performances could be sans trophy (without even needing a judging fiasco).

In the end, I live for performing and that sense of accomplishment, so I'd rather not get too fixated on trophies, prizes and ribbons. But it is a flaw in the format that I feel deserves a second look.
 

Harman

Member
Messages
189
Sue Sylvester said:
faizan said:
sue, real quick, doesn't elite 8 only have one winner with no award for 2 or 3? I think a championship should only go to 1 team, personally.
I think the difference is that half the line-up that wins their match-up goes home with recognition as oppose to just 1 team winning 1 award. Teams with weaker performances could potentially get a trophy and teams with stronger performances could be sans trophy (without even needing a judging fiasco).

In the end, I live for performing and that sense of accomplishment, so I'd rather not get too fixated on trophies, prizes and ribbons. But it is a flaw in the format that I feel deserves a second look.
Sue, from what i can gather if i was team b then i would rather walk away with nothing then a consolation prize. Sure there is an overall winner but really this competition was about the individual matchups. Teams were matched up based on style, so team b had a 50/50 chance to walk away with some hardware.
 

PunjabiSniper

New Member
Messages
17
First of all .. before i post ... my names Vijay ... sorry about the BTF name ... *PRETTY FOLKIN EMBARASSING*

I came n danced with GCC at this years WBBC .... all i can say is ... AEG killllllllllllled it with this comp ... cant believe how well they looked after us. They went above and beyond what i'd consider reasonable and thats why we had so much fun ... CRAZY EXPERIENCE overall! shoutout BK and Furteelay lads who so safe!!

MIXER::

Mixer was actually so much fun ... i only had a samosa but it tasted bloody good from what i remember! the way they had the matchups dance together was such a sick touch ... n the MIXER tshirt is so good that im actually guna frame it and hang it in front of my graduation photo.

Also shoutout to FAIZAN on the mic ... this guy shud be a full time comedian ... love the way he drops sly jokes about all the teams ... he made it pretty entertaining

(special mention to the singh who was jumping through a hoop in the mixer for his team ... what a G)

PRACTICE SPACE:

a lot of people have mentioned the practice space thing but i actually enjoyed it quite a bit ... there was so much room to dance in the car park that it was actually wkd blasting music from the car and practicing ... thats 1 of the highlights because it was just so random!!

TECH TIME:

Aeg took us to the venue in good time ... gave us the full 20min and everything was perfect ... cant complain

COMP::

The actual comp was amazing ... atmosphere with the teams at the back was so chilling ... every1 was just enjoyin it ... shoutout to Dilbagh for tying some of our paghs ... that guy was everywhere on the night.

WELL DONE TO ALL THE TEAMS ... Furteelay n BK smashed it ... congrats on winning the battles and also Well done to Cornell for winning overall ... those gimmicks were crazzzzzzzyyyyyy!!!

I think GCC missed a trick by not putting in any gimmicks ... but hey ... was a great learning curve for most of our dancers nonetheless.

AFTERPARTY::

Afterparty got locked off ... it was still not a big deal cz every1 who was jammin in the lobby afterwards had jokes ... it was like a party down there anyway!!!

Shoutout to the singh who saved me n 2 others from getting raped by 4 black dudes dressed as women in the lift ... me rav n sunil r forever indebted to you!!!


OVERALL::

Thank you soo muchhhh to AEG - ankush, ash and the gang were madddd friendly ... n MASSIVE THANKS TO MAVI our liaison ... that guy was soooo helpful and ona level ... he was there for us 24/7 ... also thanks to Kiranjeet for taking us to a Walmart on the West Coast (jokin).

OVERALL 10/10 ... i wouldnt have changed a thing about this comp ... u can tell its going to get bigger and better ... THIS YEAR HAS LAID THE FOUNDATIONS FOR AN AMAZING COMP TO FLOURISH in the future!!!

BIG UPPPPP EVERY SINGLE PERSON INVOLVED n thank you to anyone who was supporting!!!!

#WBBC2014
 
Top