• Bhangra discussion is still going strong. Join us in our Facebook group!

    New user registration has been closed (as it was entirely spam). We encourage you to post in our Facebook group, even if it's a followup to an existing thread. BTF will continue to be archived and hosted here - Saleem

Bhangra set labeled as "too folk"????

Status
Not open for further replies.

J-Skeet

New Member
Messages
252
So as we all know T-Dot Bhangra competition 2012 went off to be huge success this past weekend. Congrats to all of the placing teams and the committee for throwing a great competition. Once again CONGRATS!!!
Back to topic
So apparently it was said that a team was told by the judges outright that their set was "too folk". Specifically this team was Virsa Folkstars. It was also said they this was the reason why they didn't place.
Normally I could care less why a team didn't place, but I've watched their set and Virsa definitely had a placing performance. I'll attach the video too. Anyway not only was this a good set, but the whole "too folk" response by the judges has me personally a little perturbed. Now I wasn't there in the judges room and I can't speak for the judges, but my question is how can a team be labeled as too folk? We've seen in the circuit that teams are labeled by other teams as "too folk" as well. I mean even if we take out what the Judges supposedly said at T-Dot how can teams be labeled as "too folk".


In context: I'm pretty sure we can all understand that if at a fusion competition a team can get labeled as having too much Bhangra. However, if a set contains only Bhangra and it's a Bhangra competition then how can it be too folk?

Virsa Folkstars at T-Dot 2012
 

Bhangra Critic

New Member
Messages
57
I think the judges used the wrong words. The term "too folk" should never be the wording or even the reason for a team not placing, because whether its a modern competition or traditional competition the dance is Bhangra, which is a traditional dance. Now as for the performance, personally I can understand why they didn't place because first off competitions across North America are trying to establish themselves as the "go-to" competition of the year, and because of this they have to sell what they are presenting. Now before I start ranting and get people all defensive, this is my personal opinion of what I believe is happening in our bhangra society and if you don't agree great if you do that's awesome also. Now let me simply start with saying, contradictory what i said before, traditional, not necessarily folk, traditional bhangra in NA is dead. This is more towards modern /music categories. Its simply 8 man sets with the diagonal lines, circles,windows, its not getting you any wins at these big modern comps. This relates a lot to the audience, people just don't wanna see that anymore, and they wanna see the new tricks, larger teams, modern influences(NA music) or gimmicks and that what competitions are looking for now as well. So back to why they didn't place, not because it wasn't good, because it was and well done, but thats coming from a bhangra dancers view, to an audience/competition it was nothing but a simple set. Traditional bhangra now only lives in live/dhol sets, which is why i'm against girls doing live bhangra. Now, lets jus get this straight i do not hate girls or against women's rights or anything. In my view its alreasy great that women have joined the modern bhangra scene, but its more like would you see guys do a gidha show? Maybe I'm wrong, but once again, this is just one guys opinion.
 

Bhangra Critic

New Member
Messages
57
Quick note, some might say what the diff. in folk and traditional. The way i see it and was talking about in my unreasonably long paragraph is that folk is simple bringing out the grace of bhangra, meaning nakhra, shoulders, smile,and simply looking like your having fun. While i see traditional as what we would see in a live set as 8 guys, dhol, and similar sequences each time khunda/chika then jhumar,dhamal, etc. Hopefully makes sense.
 

J-Skeet

New Member
Messages
252
Just to clarify guys don't let the whole Virsa-TDOt thing throw you off. This is meant to be a generic topic and I used what apparently happened to Virsa as a base. Yes, I do believe that the Judge phrased his/her critique wrong and yes this topic has been touched upon several times before, but it has to be brought up again. What is folk? The same can be said about a "modern" team. How can we label a team as "too modern".
 

arrun98

New Member
Messages
25
I dont think a team can be dubbed being "to folk"
One thing i gotta say is that teams being more folk is what is lacking in some bhangra competitions. The new modern sets are great and amazing and i mean AMAZING! But some teams have to go back to there roots and go a bit folk. At the end of the day, it all depends on what going through the judges heads. Either if the prefer Folk or Modern. ;)
 

Kartik

Member
Messages
319
A set can easily be "too folk" or "too modern" based on the competition rubric. I've been told that our set was "too modern" for Burgh and "too folk" for Boston.

An abstraction of the terms folk and modern is useless but they have important meanings within the context of a competition.
 

voxanimus

<('.'<) (>'.')>
Messages
1,685
Kartik said:
A set can easily be "too folk" or "too modern" based on the competition rubric. I've been told that our set was "too modern" for Burgh and "too folk" for Boston.

An abstraction of the terms folk and modern is useless but they have important meanings within the context of a competition.

kartik's right on the money; competitions have rather defined aesthetics that they've created for themselves, and that they seek to fulfill on a consistent basis. a given performance can fall either left or right of a competition's particular niche, and in doing so net itself a "too modern" or "too folk" criticism.
 

singhta27

Bhangre de Raja, Dil ah da shahanshah
Messages
37
Theres no such thing as "too folk", classic song selection , and majority of the set was clean , good job boys , keep killing it :)
 

faizan

Just shut up and dance
Messages
1,736
"too folk" really just means: "too boring for our competition"



"not folk enough" really just means: "too exciting for our competition"


:p
 

amancheema

Active Member
Messages
240
awesome set... no random river dancing, gimmicks, hip hop, america's best dance crew nonsense etc... just bhangra haha I love it


this set and your garden state set = 2 of the best sets performed in 2012


really hope to see the Virsa boys compete more often this season
 

Kaur

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,294
faizan said:
"too folk" really just means: "too boring for our competition"



"not folk enough" really just means: "too exciting for our competition"


:p
+1
 

Kaur

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,294
Usually a competition wants to have a certain image. Some are modern comps ( Boston, bruin, Vibc) and some are traditional (burgh, jashan, dda). And the comps that like to have a mixture of both are the ones where teams sometimes complain about placings because they whole 'best of both worlds' thing doesn't always work.

Look at the history of each competition to see what kind of teams have been placing the past few years and see which one is right for your team. It's not always black and white but it's a good way to filter :) Worked for us.
 

Govind

Member
Messages
364
I don't know who was judging, but in general, it would be more helpful for you to clarify these type of things with the actual judges who made the comments and not take 2 words out of context and leave it to btf to guess what they meant.
 

Saab

Today is a gift
Messages
991
Lucky holy shit man that was awesome.

To the thread at hand, you should never throw those words out there. To sweepingly generalize the set in the feedback session in those terms(or even the "it is too modern") isn't useful at all. The judges should start explaining it, and if there is no time, continue talking behind the scenes or a the venue later on. It's kinda useless to speculate what those words meant, and also, your feedback should be relative to your performance( Judges who ask for a video or watch a video personally before reiterating feedback taint the whole concept of real-time feedback - its a one shot thing folks).

I really don't know what to make of what's said. I just find it inexcusable for judges to not be able to explain these things in a manner conducive to a feedback session (note: not putting judges on blast - I am only going off of one side of the story).
 

singhk1

New Member
Messages
416
Thers no such thing as too folk this team is one of the best teams in the circuit I love this dam team really do..I just wish they did a different set cuz this is the same one they did in jersey
 

Kartik

Member
Messages
319
desi99 said:
"too folk" also means "too clean"


good stuff virsa
Not at all; Empire's considered one of the cleanest teams out there, I doubt you'd consider them "folk".

"Folk" is an attempt at describing a style, which is subjective and semi-arbitrary. "Clean" is a measure of an absolute - unrelated to what the movement is.
 

voxanimus

<('.'<) (>'.')>
Messages
1,685
Kartik said:
desi99 said:
"too folk" also means "too clean"


good stuff virsa
Not at all; Empire's considered one of the cleanest teams out there, I doubt you'd consider them "folk".

"Folk" is an attempt at describing a style, which is subjective and semi-arbitrary. "Clean" is a measure of an absolute - unrelated to what the movement is.

i think the statement works, but only one way. a "folk" team is most likely very clean, but a "clean" team is not at all required to be folk
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top