**BTF Remix Challenge 8: Swizzee (8) vs. DJ Preet (7)**

[yraparla]

[SIZE=small]Voting for this challenge will end at 9:00[/SIZE][SIZE=small] PM EST, Sunday, July 10, 2011[/SIZE]

Original Song is Gadian te Gallan by Balwinder Bhatti
Balwinder Bhatti - Gadian te Gallan/Sorni


[SIZE=small]-- Attached are 2 mixes from the BTF Remix Ladder Challenge and the original song they were based off
-- Vote on which mix YOU think is better, and give a brief description why (nothing too in depth, unless you feel compelled to)[/SIZE]
- - Please listen to both of the tracks, vote and then read the comments. The download ratio in the other thread is very unbalanced!
[SIZE=small]-- VOTING BY COMMENTING ONLY! [/SIZE][SIZE=small]Please guys, for the sake of the competition, please do vote. Having numerous downloads with no votes defeats the purpose of this competition and will result in its failure in the future.[/SIZE]

 

[Armaan]

Track A wins my vote.

For whoever made track B, please understand (and I'm sure others will agree), that in terms of mixing I feel that you barely did anything to the track. All in all Track B practically sounds like the original.

 

[vaibhav]

Track A!

 

[faysal]

track A clean and fresh, don't really like the original song but I could listen to this.

 

[nb0913]

Track A

 

[GSingh]

Mix A was better. The level of mixing was far greater and the idea itself brought a fresh take on the otherwise pretty bland song. props.

 

[G.O.O.D.Music]

Track A

 

[BBC]

Track B.
Simplicity.

 

[ramzfan91]

Track A - creative on the beats used, mastered great


Track B was simple but to the point where the t-pain song was completely overrun and it did sound like the original

 

[Tanveer K]

Track A !

 

[Kush]

This is my first vote for the competition, and man what a pleasure. Ive decided every time i vote i'll be listening to the original before either mix to understand what was the mixer and what was the song.


Track A. Hands down. It became a completely new song, 100000x better than the original.

Track B. I like what you were trying to do, but i'm not sure it was executed to its full potential. The beat needed to have a stronger presence, and also when the vocals dropped i'm pretty sure the vocal scheme clashed. Def had potential here though.

 

[akshyz]

Track A - mad clean.

 

[Nikhil]

Track A for sure. Damn that was ridiculous

 

[ranjit singh]

track A for sure

 

[Love]

Gotta go with Track A in this one. Clean mixing, everything was fun to listen to. Don't really like the song given to mix itself, but track A was more enjoyable than both the original and track B

 

[rajiv0224]

Track A. Same reasoning as GSingh.

 

[Basim]

My vote: Track A

Wasn't a big fan of the original track, but here is my review..

Track A: Wow, that was impressive. The intro was great.. brought some hype right away starting with a lower volume and increasing to the main level. Love what you did by incorporating the various songs.. it just flowed so well and the beats matched up really well. Great job on EQing the mix.


Track B: I agree with Armaan in that it sounds like you barely did anything to the track. I kept thinking "where is the mixing?" when I heard your track. You're gonna have to show more effort if you don't want to sink to the bottom in this mixing challenge.


Keep it up!


~ Basim

 

[Baldeep]

Track A: didn't like the english part(sounded like a punjabi song with some random black dude singing in it)
Track B: Sounded really plain.
Vote : Track A

 

[Romy]

Track A gets my vote.

 

[voxanimus]

Track A: wow. just wow. i wish i had 1% of your mixing skills. shit.
Track B: i almost couldn't hear what actually the mixing was. Aside from the hoi's. so i can't really critique.


track A gets my vote.