Saleem said:
Vic, not to beat this to death but let's suppose E8 picks NJ and Shan-E from Canada East. Would you say that they are a "talented group of guys and [are] able to put great routines on stage." or would you say SGPD has competed more widely and more successfully than Shan-E Punjab?
It is fair to say that SGPD has competed more widely and more successfully then Shan-E. But the problem everyone is having is why Virsa over SMD. I do not know how many times each team has competed or placed but there can not be that much of a difference. They have both competed enough since the last E8 and both teams are capable of being considered "Elite". It's up to the Elite 8 committee to chose teams. In regards to Shan-E and SGPD, I'm sure if Shan-e compete more often, Elite 8 would have a serious problem picking teams from Canada East.