DJ 1: Doesnt sound like there are any layers beyond drums. This makes your track feel empty and lack character. Explore using instrumentals to enhance the vibe of the track.
DJ 2: I dig the intro and the vibe! I get a double dhamaal vibe from the instrumental and would've loved to see an appropriate dhol loop to complement the whole thing! A added snare or clap wouldve driven this mix more in that direction too. I was able to feel a drop in this mix, but its still a vibe.
DJ 3: I appreciate your effort to incorporate the sher. However, your choice of instrumental/sample (the wood block thing) was not good. I suggest using instrumentals that fit the vibe of the song to complement in. The goal isn't to make any two things fit, but to make 2 complementary tracks feel like they belong with each other.
DJ 4: Theres just too much bass. The vocals felt buried under the chaos of the dhols and drums. its definitely the most creative mix in this group, but I wish it was executed in a cleaner fashion for the drop. All your layers were decently mixed with each other but not mixed well with the vocals for me. I would recommend mixing things around the vocals and then working on clarity of those layers without sacrificing the presence of the vocals.
DJ 5: I dig the arrangement, but the drums are either not present or lack the loudness and punch they deserve to drive the listener.
1st: DJ 2
2nd: tie between DJ 4 & 5 - both in my opinion have some aspect (drums/vocals) of the mixdown which was overlooked, but are better than others