muqabla89 said:
our team has been to competitions like so you think you can naach in atlanta and at rangoli in mercer...even they had qualified judges..i dont mean "collaborate" you idiot..i mean that they should figure out frm them some decent judges for the bhangra category..i kno some teams applying (besides ours) and i can tell u rite now that its not gona be an alll modern comp..there's gona be a few good teams there..why wudnt bhangra fans in texas come out to this? im pretty sure that if there's even a decent lineup out..that ppl in texas will go...when i meant that this competitoin shud talk to texas showdown ppl im speaking specifically for the bhangra category so that there is fair and accurate judging...
-justin singh virk
ecu muqabla
If you want me to take you seriously and discuss this competition with you in a professional manner, please be respectful. Keep in mind, you are not only respresenting yourself, but are also representing your team on BTF.
I don't understand how your statement:
"i mean that they should figure out frm them some decent judges for the bhangra category" differs from mine:
"I do agree that they need better judges for this competition though.. or at least have seperate judges to judge each particular dance." Once again, let me restate that I agree with you that they need better judges (especially for the bhangra category) and I don't feel there can be universal judges that can judge both Raas & Bhangra.
I have no idea why Texas Showdown was brought into this, but like I said, both R2B2 and Texas Showdown cater toward different audiences. R2B2 has been around a lot longer than Texas Showdown, so I'm sure they know how to run a competition. The bhangra teams that come to R2B2 know that it is not a primarily traditional competition, they know what types of teams that apply based on the past lineups, and if they have any questions on judging.. those should be asked before applying/competiting. You mentioned
"i meant that this competitoin shud talk to texas showdown ppl im speaking specifically for the bhangra category so that there is fair and accurate judging." Sure, they could talk to Texas Showdown to figure out how to judge the bhangra competition side better, but you do realize that this competition will never have "fair and accurate" judging when both of these distinctly difference dances are grouped together and judges are asked to judge BOTH. Teams that are applying to R2B2 should know this simple fact and if they don't, they should realize it fairly quickly.
If you haven't noticed, I'm from Texas and have seen the progess of both of these competitions from when they first started. You stated
"why wudnt bhangra fans in texas come out to this? im pretty sure that if there's even a decent lineup out..that ppl in texas will go." Obviously Bhangra & Raas fans in Texas will go (as the SMU campus crowd serves to be the primary audience), but when did I mention Texas people? I said
"why would hardcore bhangra fans come to a Raas + Bhangra competition... especially when a bigger bhangra-only competition like VIBC in around the same time?" I didn't mean Texas fans, I meant people wanting to come spectate this competition in general (like people go to VIBC to experience that competition).
Once again, if you care to respond, please do so in respect manner to the aforementioned statements. We can always continue this discussion outside of BTF as well, so please PM me for my contact details.
~ Basim